Monday, January 11, 2010

Pak Gus

By Anand Krishna, *The voice in the wilderness* - The Jakarta Post - Jakarta, Indonesia
Saturday, January 2, 2010

The "voice" is gone. And we are left with wilderness.

Gus Dur, the voice that made the wilderness less terrifying, shall no longer be heard. His was the voice of hope, the voice that kept the flame of hope burning in many hearts. Alas, that voice is gone. And yet, on second thought, where can it go? The echo of each and every word he ever uttered shall remain here. Right here, with you and with me - with all of us.

Back in 1998, when I first met him, it was Christmas morning right in the holy month of Ramadan. Sitting beside him, talking to him and exchanging notes. I realized the man, said to be blind, was actually the only one in the entire country who could see things as they were. He was the only man with sight living among us, the blind.

I realized the man next to me was no ordinary man. He was a leader of an altogether different genre. He was a Sufi, a man of God. I remember his words on my tape: "Pak Anand, all conflicts are caused by self-interest . Triggered by mistrust . We need to know and appreciate each other, as you rightly say. Our youth must learn this important lesson."

Commenting on the role of religion and its relation to the state, he said, "The essence of all religions is *togetherness'. There are groups of people trying to change our state's Constitution. We must have a Constitution acceptable to all, and not to any particular group only.

"I work unceasingly to bring about harmony among the different religious groups . There are groups of people busy highlighting the differences among us. There are differences, but not too many. Why shouldn't we, instead, highlight the similarities among us?"

"This is where you, your friends, we all must come and work together!" And that we did.

For more than a decade after that first meeting, we stood together. Rather, he stood together with us, with all of us, in our struggle to uphold the unity and integrity of our beloved country.
Whether it was the religious-triggered conflicts in Jakarta, or outside; the houses of worship attacked, burned and ransacked by the extremists; the so-called insensitive porn bill passed by our parliament ignorant of our indigenous culture and values; or any other struggle - the man stood by us.

Even frail and weak, he was always at the forefront of all our campaigns. He was, he is, the symbol of our struggle, the struggle of this nation toward a truly democratic state, where the concept of majority and minority no longer matters.

Not that we agreed on all issues. I did not see eye to eye on his political role. I considered him too big, a giant of a man, to occupy a relatively small presidential seat. I wrote and said to him, "Gus, you are a kingmaker. Presidents must come and meet you, seek your blessings *sowan in Javanese*. You are too big for the seat."

Gus Dur was silent.

Several months later, accompanying while he ate bakso (meatballs) in his room, I said, "Gus, you are needed outside the palace. The whole nation needs you." He was still silent.

Yet perhaps he was not silent. Perhaps I could not hear him. A couple of weeks later, he was outside the palace - once again among us, among his own people. The messiah of the people had returned to the people. We all celebrated the day.

I remember seeing him in Ciganjur some time back and we discussed world history. I quoted from Arnold Toynbee's A Study of World History. He was excited: "Do you have the book? Do you have it?"

He was like a little child.

I answered, "Yes, Gus, Pak." I always had difficulty calling him Gus - "big brother" in East Java dialect - and would often end up addressing him Pak Gus. A completely wrong expression that made him chuckle.

"Yes, Gus, but I don't have the complete edition, just the abridged edition."

"Oh, that's good, I must come to your place, and see it," he said, again quite innocently. Then he added, "Books must not be lent, they get lost." Once again he chuckled. His childlike innocence was divine!

For the next half an hour, we discussed nothing but books. I was reminded of my late father's meeting with first president, Bung Karno. He had a similar experience. Deja vu!

Abdurrahman Wahid, meaning the "servant of the compassionate one", was a living commentary of both his name and his belief. He served God in man, he served in the fashion of prophets, messiahs, the Buddha and avatars. His religion was the religion of love, of peace, which embraced one and all.

Born on Sept. 7, 1940, he died on Dec. 30, 2009 - and yet, how can a man as big as him die? His voice and his legacy defy death. Gus Dur remains, his voice shall always be heard.

After Bung Karno, he was the truest man of conscience ever born in this country. He was a man who lived his belief. He was not afraid to voice truth as he saw and conceived it.

No, Gus Dur, don't you expect me to bid you farewell. No. You cannot farewell unless and until this country, this nation, your beloved Indonesia fares well. As I write these lines, I can feel your presence, I can hear you. Your childlike laughter remains with us, remains with the people of Indonesia.

I wrote earlier that yours was the voice in the wilderness. And yet perhaps I was wrong. For how can the wilderness remain a wilderness when your voice is heard?

Gus Dur, you remain!

The writer is a spiritual activist and author of more than 130 books.

The Meeting Will Continue

By Staff Reporter, *Somalia: Islamists form Parliament * - Maareg Online - London, UK
Saturday, January 2, 2010

Mogadishu (Mareeg): Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a Islamist organization said Friday they have formed a parliament comprising of 41 members in a conference that has been continuing in Abudwaq town in central Somalia.

Sheikh Abdulkadir Aden was elected as the speaker of the parliament and Sheikh Abdullahi Abdi Mohamed as the first deputy speaker.

Sheikh Ali Omar Hareed was also elected as the second deputy speaker of the Islamist, Sufi parliament.

The delegates who attended in the meeting elected 41 members of parliamentarians and then the members of the new parliament elected the leadership of the parliament.

Sheikh Abdullahi Abdirahman Abu Yusuf, the spokesman of Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a, said the meeting will continue and more activities would be done.

The Sufis who are fighting against al Shabaab militants control many towns in central Somalia.

[Visit http://www.aminarts.com/ for Somali cartoons]

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Rice For Visitors

By Staff Writer, *News in pictures on Thursday* - The Straits Times - Singapore, Singapore
Friday, January 1, 2010

A Pakistani man cooks rice for visitors of the Beri Iman, a shrine of famous Sufi Saint Beri Imam, in Islamabad, Pakistan.

It is common practice for Sufi Muslims whose prayers are answered to give offerings of food to the hundreds of poor who linger regularly at the shrine. -- PHOTO: AP

For Peace And Tranquillity

By Asian News International, *Hindus, Muslims throng the shrine of Kashmir Sufi saint* - Little About - India

Thursday, december 31, 2009

Rajouri (Jammu and Kashmir): Cutting across religious lines, both Hindu and Muslim devotees thronged the dargah (shrine and grave) of Sufi saint Baba Shah Badshah in Rajouri here to observe Urs, his death anniversary on Wednesday (December 30).

On this occasion, a large number of devotees prayed for peace and tranquility in the state."We prayed, as many devotees did, that God bless this country with peace and tranquility. People should get dignity, honour and respect. For all those who have come here with pious intention, may God fulfill their wishes. This is what I prayed to God," said Adbul Rashid Qadari, a devotee.

The Hindu devotees also prayed for peace and tranquility in the region."We prayed to God to endow us with peace and tranquility in Jammu and everything should be all right. May God fulfill the wishes of all those who have come hear and may God fulfill our wishes too," said Navjot Singh, a devotee.

[Picture: View of Rajouri. Photo: Baba Ghulam Shah Badshah University, Rajouri, J&K]

Saturday, January 09, 2010

The Scholar, The Sufi, And The Fanatic

By Nadeem F. Paracha, *The scholar, the sufi, and the fanatic* - Dawn.Com Blog - Pakistan
Thursday, December 31, 2009

Roughly speaking, the political and social aspects of Islam in Pakistan can be seen as existing in and emerging from three distinct sets and clusters of thought. These clusters represent the three variations of political and social Islam that have evolved in this country: modern, popular and conservative.

The modern aspect of Islamic thought in Pakistan has its roots in the ‘Aligarh Movement’ – a nineteenth century effort launched by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan.

His analysis convinced him that the Muslims of India had failed to come to grips with the new zeitgeist emerging from the rise of western colonialism – a power driven by breakthroughs in modern scientific thought and economics, and pragmatic politics based on rational and dispassionate self-interest, all of which stemmed from the many doctrines and socio-political upheavals witnessed in the West during the ‘Age of Reason/Enlightenment.’

Ahmed strived to reinterpret the teachings of Islam so they could be brought in harmony with modern science and philosophy, helping the educated Muslims to continue holding on to their religion but through a rational and enlightened view of life.

Though accused of heresy by conservative Islamic scholars, Ahmed managed to lay the foundations of a modern college in Aligarh in an attempt to draw young Muslims away from the traditional madrassahs towards a place of learning where religious studies would be supplemented by the teaching of modern ‘secular subjects.’

The Aligarh College, that later became a university, soon spawned what came to be known as the ‘Aligarh generation’ – groups of young educated Muslims who would go on to lay the initial foundations of the Pakistan Movement and also become the intellectual engines behind the movement’s central ideological thrust.

Though the Aligarh generation was trained in western law, politics and science, it also held dear Ahmad’s notion that the Muslims of India were a separate cultural community; a thought that was molded into the Two Nation Theory by the All India Muslim League. Much has been contemplated about Jinnah’s ideological orientation, but it is rather clear that the new country was founded on an understanding of Islam that was steeped in Ahmed’s modern Islamic tradition.

The Aligarh tradition that was carried into the corridors of the state and governance of Pakistan pointed towards the new country as being a modern Muslim majority republic, as opposed to a theocratic Islamic State. In fact, the Pakistani state and governments between 1947 and 1977 used (in varying degrees) the above rationale to keep at bay the religious parties’ demand for a theocratic state. But it is also true that the modern Aligarh Muslim mindset was largely an urban phenomenon, associated with the urban middle-class elite of the Punjab and Karachi.

The majority of Muslims in what became Pakistan remained ensconced in the region’s popular variations of Islam. The so-called Barelvi Islam* that became the mainstay belief of a majority of Muslims in the subcontinent (from the nineteenth century onwards), was, as a movement, the reassuring enshrinement of the traditional hybrid-Sufism that prevailed among the Muslims due to the long periods of interaction between Sufi Islam and Hinduism.

This hybrid-Sufism, or Barelvi Islam, became the folk religion of the rural peasants, the urban proletariat and the semi-urban petty-bourgeoisie of the country. It incorporated the anti-clergy elements of Sufism, the jurisprudence doctrines of the more flexible Sunni Hanafi fiqh and, as had been the traditional practice of popular folk Islam of the region, fused these with the concept of overt religious reverence of divine concepts and people, and the accommodating forms of worship found in various shades of Hinduism.

The result was an Indian/Pakistani Muslim polity repulsed by the dogma of puritanical strains of the religion, open to the idea of modern reinterpretation of Islamic law, permissive in its sociology, and largely non-political in essence. At the same time, Barelvi Islam is criticised for being willingly embroiled in superstition and doctrinal ‘innovations.’

Though being populist and agrarian in its world view, Barelvi Islam did not negatively react to Ahmed’s modern Islamic reform. What’s more, it was the constant failure of the political exponents of puritanical Islamic thought to penetrate the thick veneer of Barelvi Islam surrounding the rural and urban masses of Pakistan that in turn facilitated the moderate Aligarh Muslim thought and tradition within the Pakistani state to continue deflecting theocratic maneuvers in the country’s overall political polity.

As various forms of Ahmed’s modern and rational Islamic notions continued to dictate the Pakistani state’s (albeit anti-pluralistic) politics, the masses-oriented make-up of Barlevi Islam became the chosen venue of populist politics in Pakistan.

The left-leaning Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) became the first Pakistani political party to set the tone of its manifesto and rhetoric according to the populist imagery of Barelvi Islam, in the process managing to attract the urban working classes and the rural peasantry towards its socialist program. Consequently, not only did the PPP chairman, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, became one of the first major Pakistani political figures to start being seen indulging in rituals associated with Barelvi Islam (such as visiting Sufi shrines), PPP rallies themselves started radiating an aura of the colourful and musical activity found outside many Sufi shrines of the region (such as the dhamal).

The 1970s in Pakistan thus became an era of populist extroversion. With Barelvi Islam adopted as a populist political expression by the ruling PPP. This saw a further hybridisation of Barelvi Islam. This form of expression eventually became the cultural and religious connect between the country’s secular political parties, the working classes and the peasants.

However, as the popular variation of Islam in Pakistan peaked in the 1970s, the modern variation (tied to the Aligarh thought) started to erode. Though the popular variation remained very much the focus of the populist Z A. Bhutto regime, things started to change at state level when after the 1971 East Pakistan debacle, a move was seen afoot in the army towards conservative (and elitist) variations of Islam, especially those advocated by renowned Islamic scholar and Jamaat-i-Islami (JI) chief, Abul Ala Maududi.

The JI was an early advocate of what became to be known as Political Islam – a modern political theory that forwards the ‘historical’ and theological arguments for an evolutionary instatement of an Islamic state (or a modern-day caliphate) run on the dictates of the Shariah as an alternative to the capitalist-democratic system and socialism/communism.

Political Islam first emerged as an opponent of secular/socialist Muslim nationalism in the 1950s and 1960s. After Egypt, Syria and Jordan’s defeat at the hands of Israel in 1967, secular Muslim nationalism started to give way to Political Islam.

Since the theological aspects of Political Islam were opposed to the more populist strains of the faith (such as Barelvi Islam), the JI in Pakistan was eventually successful in converting the urban middle-classes to its cause after these classes stopped resonating with the modern reformist variations of Islam in Pakistan. Thus, the urban bourgeoisie and the petty-bourgeoisie became the main players against the populist Bhutto regime during the 1976 PNA movement (led by the JI).

But it wasn’t until the arrival of the Ziaul Haq dictatorship and the anti-Soviet ‘Afghan Jihad’ that Political Islam managed to find state approval. Furthermore, as both the US and Saudi Arabia pumped in billions of dollars of aid so that Zia could construct an effective jihad against the Soviet Army in Afghanistan, the more aggressive and puritanical strains of Islam (such as the Deobandi and Wahahbi) too began finding official sanction.

Conscious of the hold Barelvi Islam had in Pakistan, the Zia regime also attempted to penetrate and regulate Sindh and Punjab’s shrine culture, trying to align Barelvi thought with the clergy and jihad-heavy strains of conservative Islam that he was advocating.

The results were devastating. The corruption emerging from the large amounts of financial aid and state patronage Political Islam was able to enjoy in Pakistan during the Afghan jihad, steadily clipped away the intellectual aspects of the theory, and by 1989 (at the end of the Afghan war), Political Islam had become an empty shell in the hands of various Pakistani intelligence agencies who then filled this shell up with what would eventually surface as sheer fanaticism in the shape of sectarian organisations and phenomenon like the Taliban.

This fanaticism is now not only the militant mainstay of anti-intellectual and fanatic Islamist organisations, but, as a rude social discourse, it is being attracting a large number of the urban middle-classes as well who now seem completely detached from their early moorings towards the modern variations of Islam, and as well as from the faith’s more populist base.

Political Islam suffered from its overindulgence in an unpopular and puritanical theological feast that came attached with the patronage it got from conservative Muslim monarchies and dictatorships. By the early 1990s, it was as good as dead due to the many failures it faced to transform Muslim countries into living Islamic states.

However, it regenerated itself as a far more brutal, literalist and anti-intellectual fascist battle cry (in the shape of ‘Islamism’), which has not only been able to find support among the most desperate sections of the Pakistani society, but, unfortunately, also in the seemingly intellectually bankrupt edifice of urban middle-class Pakistan.

Nadeem F. Paracha is a cultural critic and senior columnist for Dawn Newspaper and Dawn.com.

* Click to Barelvi Islam

Determined To Win

By APP, *Sufis, Khanqaahs play vital role is spreading Islam: Sardar Aseef* - Associated Press of Pakistan - Pakistan

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Islamabad: Advisor to the Prime Minister for Education Sardar Aseef Ahmad Ali Wednesday said on Thursday that the institution of ‘Sufis and Khanqaahs’ in the sub-Continent has played a vital role in spreading Islam, influencing the policies of rulers and also the lives of the masses.

He said this while addressing the audience on the occasion of the launching ceremony of Dr. Fatima Hussain’s Book “The War that wasn’t: The Sufis and The Sultan” held at Pakistan Academy of Letters (PAL).

He said that the book is an attempt at analysing various manifestations and functions of the Sufi and his Khanqaah in the sultanate period.

This book analyses the subtle nuances of the dynamics of Sufi power in the social politics of the Delhi Sultanate and how this power affected the relations between the Sufi and the Sultanate, the two most powerful institutions in medieval India, he added.

He said that the author’s objective in the book has been to examine the broad bases of Sufi history in the Sultanate period to obtain sufficient evidence to suggest the need for a new approach and this book shows that the author has succeeded in attaining her objectives.

Sardar Aseff Ahmed said Sufism is very close to his heart as it best projects the true image of Islam.

“We can defeat terrorism by following Sufism as it will help people to understand real teachings of Islam”, he added.

The Advisor said war against terrorism is being imposed on the country but the government is determined to win it.

The other participants, who spoke on the occasion were Vice Challenger of Allama Iqbal Open University Dr. Mehmood ul Hasan Butt, Dr. Tariq Rehman and Prof. Khawaja Masood.
They highlighted different aspects of the book and said by following Sufism people can understand the real teaching of Islam.

The Chairman Pakistan Academy of Later (PAL) Fakhar Zaman said that PAL is planning to arrange International Conference of Sufism from March 14 to 19.

About 80 delegates from 40 countries are likely to participate in the conference and PAL would translate Sufi poets books in 8 different languages.

The translated books would be given to all the participants as it will help to project true image of Islam.

[Picture: Babur Receives a Courtier, 1589, Opaque watercolor and gold on paper. Photo: Wiki, Delhi Sultanate.]

Friday, January 08, 2010

A Message Of Peace

By n/a, *Top Muslim visits Nelson mosque on anti-extremism peace mission* - Pendle Today - UK
Tuesday, December 29, 2009

A Top Muslim leader who acts as an advisor to world leaders has given a message of peace and love to Pendle.

Sufi Shaykh Hisham Kabbani visits local mosques to challenge extremist agendas and lead discussions for tolerance and moderation.

His life work is to spread the teachings of peace, tolerance, respect and love throughout the world to people of every background, ethnicity, race and belief. To fulfil his commitment to empower Muslims in Britain to live from these principles, Sufi Kabbani has been touring England and conducting an outreach initiative.

On Friday evening, he visited the Central Ghausia Mosque, Nelson, to deliver a keynote speech on love and spirituality. An open invitation was extended to all community members regardless of background to attend the auspicious event.

Imam Irfan Chishti said: "Shaykh Hisham being a leading and world-renowned scholar is successfully bringing to the forefront of the Muslim community important discussions on the need to make a positive and peaceful contribution to the society of the UK. His message is clear and unambiguous for all, especially young people".

Sufi Kabbani condemns all acts of terrorism and the use of Islam to promote terrorist agendas. He has addressed world bodies such as the United Nations and has met heads of state including George Bush, Bill Clinton, President Bambang Yudhoyono of Indonesia, prime ministers from Malaysia, Afghanistan and Turkey.

He continues to advise the United States Department of State on issues regarding Islam, religious tolerance and terrorism.

[Picture: Shaykh Hisham Kabbani. Photo: Wiki]

6,000 Lines

By TE/HGH, *Shajarian joins Gharibpour's 'Mowlavi'* - Press TV - Tehran, Iran
Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Iranian vocalist Homayoun Shajarian has joined the Mowlavi puppet opera project by Iranian theater director Behrouz Gharibpour.

The son of Iran's legendary vocalist will be joined by 16 other vocalists including Mohammad Motamedi, Maliheh Moradi, Amer Shadman, Farhad Asadi and Ehsan Nasiri.

Gharibpour's Mowlavi opera will be made based on the Sufi Persian poet Mowlavi's magnum opus Masnavi and will focus on his life and intellectual development. The score for the opera was recorded in Ukraine, where Iranian and Ukrainian choirs were accompanied by dotar and percussion instruments.

Gharibpour has based his latest work on 6,000 lines from the 13th-century poet's Masnavi and used over 100 puppets to perform the opera.

Known for his extensive research on Qajar puppetry, Gharibpour has staged his puppet plays in numerous domestic and foreign festivals, including the 11th World Festival of Puppet Art in Prague and the 2008 International Incanti Figure Theatre Festival in Italy.

Gharibpour received the Sirene d'Oro [Golden Mermaids] Prize of Italy's 2009 Arrivano dal Mare [They arrive from the sea] Puppet Festival for his contribution to the art of puppetry.

Macbeth, Ashura and Rostam and Sohrab puppet operas are among his best-known works.

Thursday, January 07, 2010

A Sense Of Carnival

By Osama Kamal, *Disciple of immortal beings* - Al-Ahram Weekly - Cairo, Egypt
Issue # 978 / 24-30 December 2009

The auditorium in the Badrakhan Library was rather compact. It is an all purpose room, doubling as a space for arts exhibition, book signings and art performances. Tonight there is a concert by Sheikh Badr and the auditorium is packed to full capacity.

For those who know Badr, this is a night not to be missed. The performer's repertoire ranges from Sufi chanting to sira (folk hero tales) accounts. There is also a lot of religious singing in Badr's repertoire, for how can you have folk singing without religious crooning?

Everything in the hall is oriental -- the decoration, the accessories, even the carpets and chairs. However, a modern art show is still on, and the avant-garde paintings of Issam El-Gabkhangi seem to be taken by surprise by the oriental revivalism of the venue, soon to be taken to another level by the village music that we are here to enjoy.

The audience around me are a mix of old and young. The curious young are hoping for a glimpse of the past, and the old -- no doubt -- are merely nostalgic. Not long ago, concerts such as tonight's were a common occurrence in every Egyptian village. At a wedding or a moulid (saint's day), when people travelled or came back, the crooners sang the siras and performed the mawwals (love songs in the ballad style), and intonated Sufi poetry from dusk to dawn. Tonight is only different in the venue, but the performers are the real deal.

Sheikh Badr is here with a band of four musicians playing the violin, the tambourine, the drum and the rababa (a string instrument). Sheikh Badr is against introducing any Western instrument in folk singing. He sees the use of Western musical instruments as a corruption of tradition. "Our folk instruments are unique in their effect, and they are the reason oriental folk music is so attractive to Westerners," he says. The only instrument of a Western denomination in the band is the violin, and even that is of arguably oriental origin.

The faces of the musicians bear the unmistakable southern features. They have come from al-sayeed al-gowani, or the southernmost parts of the country, announces Sheikh Badr with pride. He is from Kom Ombo near Aswan, a descendant of the mighty Jaafari tribe.

Badr takes the stage with the vitality of a singer at a wedding, singing one village hit after another. Many city people can recognise the songs, as several have been on the radio or used in film scores. He starts with Al-bint beida beida wana amel eh (The girl is white, so white, what do I do?). Then he goes through a dozen of old hits, such as Lagl ennabi (For the sake of the Prophet), Khodni maak yallenta mesafer (Take me with you, traveller). At one point he tantalises the audience with a few stanzas from Al-Sira Al-Helaliya, (oral history of the Hilly tribe).

When I talk to Badr after the show, he reminds me of the late Zakaria El-Heggawi, the great man of folk art, the uncontested sponsor and primary keeper of musical tradition. It was El-Heggawi who first created the Nile Band, of which Badr is still a member.

El-Heggawi toured every part of the country, east and west, south and north in search of songs and lyrics, of oral history and village tales. He died in 1975, but his spirit and art are very much alive, so is the Nile Band under the current management of Abdel-Rahman El-Shafei.
Some of the Nile Band first generation singers are still around, Fatema Sarhan and Gamalat Shiha included. Others are now dead: Khadra Mohamed, Mohamed Abu Deraa and Rayyes Metqal. But their imprint on folk singing is not gone and their memory is cherished to this day by a new generation of performers.

The Nile Band has for decades been Egypt's primary emissary to international forums and festivals, equalled only in this respect by the Reda Folk Dance Company, the country's primary folk dance company. Badr has travelled with the Nile Band to Tunisia, Morocco, Italy and France. He remembers these trips with relish, and is pleased with the recognition Egyptian folk art receives abroad.

Over the past few years Badr has appeared in more than one stage play, including Sirr Al-Hawa (Secret of Love), in which he sang the popular saga of Hassan and Naima. In one scene in the play Badr performed a duet with the popular singer Ali El-Haggar, which consistently brought the audience to their feet. Badr also appeared in the play Taam Al-Sabbar (Taste of Cactus) with Azza Husseini, which had two long runs at the Hanager Theatre.

Together with artist Hamdi Hussein, Badr appeared in the stage play Ghenwet Al-Leil (Song of the Night), which told the saga of Shafiqa and Metwalli. He also sang Al-Sira Al-Helaliya at the Popular Culture Theatre in Fayoum.

Badr is the scion of the Mashayekh family of Kom Ombo. He had a religious education and began singing as a child. His maternal grandfather, Sheikh Hammad, is something of a local saint and his paternal grandfather, Sheikh Taha, is a well- known Sufi figure.

Badr says that Kom Ombo is mostly a conservative community with Sufi leanings and pronounced spirituality, and that him being specialised in religious singing should come as no surprise. In his community people listen to religious singing almost daily. Badr's first album in 2005, Ya Rayhin Al-Madina (You Who Go To Madina), was a collection of religious songs.

Badr's personal style is folksy and cheerful. When you listen to Badr, it's as if you are at a moulid. There is a sense of carnival, a levity of gesture and lots of humour. The cheerfulness does not even disappear when Badr goes into a sira (traditional songs about folk heroes). Comfortable as he is in his sira singing, he does not consider himself to be one the great sira singers among the likes of Sayed El-Dawi and Gaber Abu Hussein.

The big names of sira, he tells Al-Ahram Weekly, not only sang but lived the sira. Badr believes he is just a disciple of those immortal greats, a man who walks on their trail, just as Zakaria El-Heggawi once did.

Wednesday, January 06, 2010

Lahw Wa La’b?

By Asghar Ali Engineer, *Is Music prohibited in Islam ?* . TwoCircles.net - Cambridge, MA, USA

Thursday, December 24, 2009

The other day I read an article in Friday edition of an Urdu paper which quoted few ahadith (Prophet’s sayings) that music is strictly prohibited in Islam and that those Muslims who burn musical instruments Allah will send them to paradise. Many non-Muslims also ask this questions frequently why Islam is opposed to music? Aurangzeb is also said to have strictly prohibited music.

Is music really prohibited? My studies show it is not prohibited per se. The Qur’an denounces what it calls lahw wa la’b (i.e. fun and play and there was background to it. They Arabs in pre-Islamic times had no serious religious faith and used to indulge in drinking and singing and dancing as we often witness in our societies also. Islam, wanted to engage people in serious activities of reforming social evils and make them obedient to Allah thereby becoming good, just and compassionate human beings undertaking fight against all prevailing social evils. For such way of life naturally lahw wa la’b was serious obstacle and hence the Qur’an warned people against that.

However, many Muslims could not distinguish between the two and declared music prohibited whatever its form or context. While Ulama denounced music the Sufi saints generally approved of it and distinguishing between lahw wa la’b and sheer fun they allowed music as a tool to God-realization as music could induce a sort of ecstasy which in turn helped God-realization. Thus sama’ which literally means listening of music was practiced by sufi saints.

It was for sama’ that qawwali was invented, as far as my knowledge goes, by Khusro, the celebrated disciple of Nizamuddin Awliya who used to have sama’ mehfil (i.e. congregation for devotional music). The Ulama who were jealous of Nizamuddin Awliya’s popularity, issued a fatwa (religious edict) against him for attending sama’ mehfil and the Sultan asked him to come to his court and defend himself. He went to the Sultan’s court (otherwise he never paid court to any sultan) and defended himself by reciting certain ahadith and came away. Maulana Rum had gone a step further and even resorted to dancing to induce such divine ecstacy and his followers regularly resort to dancing and are known as whirling dervishes.

It was because of such controversies created by the Ulama that an eminent sufi and scholar like Ghazzali wrote an epistle on Status of Music in Islam – Discipline and Rules of Music and Ecstacy. It is worth reading for all those who want to understand whether Islam prohibits music or not or if prohibits, what kind of music it prohibits.

Al-Ghazzali begins his Risala on music with these words, “Know this my dear about the fact and situation of man that there is a secret of God which is hidden in the human heart, which is similar to the one that is between iron and stone. Just as fire emits when iron strikes stone and sets forest on fire, a movement occurs in the human heart when it hears good and rhythmical sounds. And unconsciously a new situation comes into existence in the heart.”

He further says “The upper world of beauty and grace and the fundamental of beauty and grace is due proportion. And, whatever is proportionate is the manifestation of the beauty of that upper world. The beauty and proportion that we see in this world is the product of the beauty and grace of the upper world. Therefore, good, rhythmical and proportionate sound has a similarity with some of the wonders of the upper world. And it provides new informations in the heart in the form of a movement and eagerness.”

And further on Ghazzali says, “Whoever’s heart is filled with the fire of the eagerness of God, music becomes necessary for him, so that the fire may be brighter. The same music becomes haram (prohibited) and poisonous for a man, whose heart is full of the love of wrongful matters.”

What is this wrongful matter, Ghazzali refers to? It is lust, fun and music meant for worldly pleasure like the ones youngsters indulge in after drinking in clubs and such other institutions. Of course the Indian Classical music does not fall in this category and it is great art and discipline. Even qawwali and ghazal singing is based on Indian classical music or for that matter western classical symphonies are well cultivated art representing best in human beauty and grace.

Of course Ghazzali does not base his epistle only on such arguments but also on ahadith which tell us how the Prophet (PBUH) himself used to listen to music along with A’isha, his beloved wife. However, for want of space we cannot dwell on this. We will discuss that in other article insha Allah.

[Picture: Abida Parveen in concert at Oslo. Photo from: Wiki.]

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Beyond Stereotypes

By Sharif Musaji, *On Religious Identity: A Modest Proposal (That Has Nothing to Do with Eating Babies) * - The American Muslim (TAM) - Bridgeton, MO, USA
Wednesday, December 23, 2009

“Of course there is no us and them
But them they do not think the same
It’s them who do not think!”
-Lyrics from Gogol Bordello’s “Illuminated”


By any traditional definition, I am not a good Muslim. This is perhaps surprising, considering my mother is the editor of The American Muslim (though I am aware there may be some people out there who don’t think she’s the best Muslim in the world either), but it’s the truth. And yet, no matter what I do, no matter how I live my life, I will always be a Muslim.

Being a Muslim is now, much like being Jewish, just as much a cultural identifier as it is a religious one. David Cross has a stand-up bit about a perplexing conversation he had with his rabbi where, even after explaining that he was an atheist, his rabbi still asserted that he was Jewish for life, simply because his mother was. Being a Muslim is kind of like that. There is no escaping it. There is no way around it. No matter how incorrect or inapplicable, “muslim” has become a vague, blanket term for pretty much anyone with a moderate tan and a fondness for samosas.*

For most of my life, this hasn’t really been a problem. But with every passing news day, it becomes more of a liability. It seems I increasingly find myself in the awkward position of fielding questions about why Islam is a religion of violence and hatred, even from people who are generally fairly sensible and level-headed. Not that this isn’t a fair question, in the sense that Islam is definitely a link in the causal chain of many recent events like the Fort Hood shooting, but to equate Islam directly with violence is, in my opinion, patently false. Such thinking represents the limited perspective that people so often view the world from. As a fairly visible voice in the American Muslim community, I see this same phenomenon happen to my mother on a much larger—and often much more confrontational—scale.

So even though I am not a scholar**, and have a limited knowledge of Abrahamic faiths, I have a proposal. It is an admittedly silly, naive, and idealistic proposal, but those are the best kind. If it helps, think of it as a thought experiment. Let’s stop using religious labels altogether. Labels like Christian or Muslim. Let’s just do away with them. Cold turkey. Done. Just like that. They are limiting terms that serve only to divide us.

Because really, in this day and age, what do these terms mean? There are dozens of Christian denominations in America alone, and that doesn’t even scratch the surface of the myriad ways that faith can manifest itself in this country and across the globe. One spiritual person might believe that believing in Jesus Christ as lord and savior is the only way to salvation, whereas another might simply believe that Jesus was a prophet, and that we should all attempt to live by his example and teachings. Both self-identify as Christians, yet both have vastly different theological worldviews. One Muslim might follow the teachings of the Sufi poet Rumi, and express his devotion to God through dance and music. Another might find dance and music distracting, or even the tools of the devil, and insist on performing her five daily prayers in a plain, empty room.

People will protest. “Our differences are what make us unique, and what brings us together. You can’t do away with thousands of years of religious tradition just like that.*** We must embrace and learn from our differences!” they’ll say, in their alarmingly whiny voices. And they have a point. But they’re still wrong. Very wrong. These complaints fail to realize that by getting rid of these inadequate terms, we will actually be honoring and enriching not only our various cultures and religious practices, but the unique beliefs of every individual. Because, as one of my favorite professors used to say, religion does not exist in a vacuum. It is an extension and product of societies and culture, politics and economics - really, of everything. So we can never speak of any religion or religious group as some monolithic entity. Religion is just one aspect of a much larger picture, not just in an individual’s life, but in a society’s. Sometimes it is a very influential aspect. Other times it is just a church or temple attached to a really nice gymnasium.

Try and imagine the change that would occur were we to stop using these labels. No longer would we be able to use them as shortcuts to reaching conclusions about people. The terms for the follower of any major religion have now become so loaded, heavy with baggage and all sorts of connotations that it’s almost silly that we do still use them. So let’s do away with them. Suddenly the discussion about Islam’s role in terrorism would instead become exactly what it should be: a discussion on the different ways people choose to interpret the Qu’ran and apply it to their lives, and what role that application plays in the larger context of their specific socio-political situation. Because that’s exactly what it is.

And we would get to that intelligent and nuanced discussion because no one would be able to take the intellectually lazy path of simply stating, “Some muslim blew himself up.” Muslims like my mother would not have to justify and defend the religion of Islam, because every individual’s religious choices, beliefs, and actions would be their own. Moreover, a troubled individual who came to the conclusion that “martyrdom” was a justifiable action would not even be related in any meaningful way to an individual like my mother, an individual with whom the teachings of the Qu’ran and Muhammad happen to have resonated deeply, but who also finds truth and meaning in the holy texts and practices of other faiths, whose worldview is still undeniably shaped by her Catholic upbringing, and who lists among her favorite books Herman Hesse’s Siddhartha.

People might take a step back, and look at the world from a new perspective. That guy read the Qu’ran and decided to hijack a plane, whereas this guy read the Qu’ran and became a conscientious objector, losing his world heavyweight boxing title and serving several years in prison instead of fighting in a war he believed was unjust. What was the difference between the two? This guy read the Bible and became a brave and courageous civil rights leader, whereas that guy read the Bible and decided to assault and murder a homosexual. Why such vastly differing outcomes? Perhaps this simple thought experiment would allow people to actually take a moment to look beyond stereotypes and broad blanket terms, and attempt to truly understand one another. Because people are not simply Christians or Muslims or Jews, they are impossibly complex and endless combinations of culture and circumstance, of socio-economic factors and pure coincidence, perfect examples of what Buddhists call dependent co-arising.

Moreover (and this is getting into super wishful thinking), doing away with these terms would allow us to enter a new age of spiritual improvement. We could all recognize each other simply as fellow travelers on the spiritual path. How much we choose to remain on that path, or even stray off of it, would be our own individual choice. All would be free to learn the valuable lessons presented by various faiths and belief systems, but also to reject the outdated, irrational, and dangerous viewpoints that we must recognize every belief system possesses. There would be a vibrant discussion and debate, and people would be flexible and free to adjust their views and even radically alter their beliefs, because they would not be constrained by labels. Religious traditions would be more vibrant and relevant than they have been in centuries, evolving and expanding in new and exciting ways.

It would be like a sumptuous religious potluck, where every soul could pick and choose the teachings and aspects of different religions and belief systems that make sense to them, constantly trying new things until arriving at the perfect meal. Strict atheists might reject every dish served at this meal, opting instead to bring their own healthy snack to the feast. All would be welcome in this exchange of ideas. I’ve heard people argue that this “buffet” style religion is inauthentic, wishy-washy, New Age-y flim-flam. Those people are mean and use too many hyphenated words. They also miss the point. Sarah Nardi, however, does not. In her article ‘Ramadan Xmas” (Adbusters #87), she presents a fascinating example of how this cross pollination might play out. She posits that Westerners might benefit from some form of fasting during or after the excess of the holiday season. “The thought of candy, cookies, credit cards - consumption in any form - invites feelings of guilt and disgust”, she writes. “Coming down from Christmas - reconnecting to my body’s natural rhythms and my mind’s natural pace - takes days… But what if we were to introduce some elements of Ramadan into our celebration of Christmas? Muslims, during the month-long observance of the Islamic holiday, abstain from eating, drinking and sex during the daylight hours. The practice of fasting is meant to teach patience, humility, and restraint… It is an exercise in discipline and meditation that, once completed, should leave one feeling more connected, more whole.”

No doubt critics will consider this yet another attack on the sanctity of Christmas. Perhaps Stephen Colbert will upgrade it to The Jihad on Christmas instead of just The War on Christmas, if he hasn’t done so already. But the point is that this commingling of ideas and traditions leads to a richer, fuller understanding of one another. Just as Ramadan could help one to appreciate Christmas in a new way, so too could the joy, warmth, and celebration of Christmas serve as yet another reminder for those observing Ramadan to make sure to treasure their loved ones. Also, fruit cake!

More than anything else, doing away with these labels will assuage the cultural guilt I have of not being a very good Muslim. I could instead become, just like everyone else on this planet, a humble pilgrim, seeking answers to thus far unanswerable questions. For my sake, if not for your own, at least think about it.

*This is the part where angry, intolerant, radical hatemongers quote the first half of that sentence, and replace “moderate tan and a fondness for samosas” with “a towel on their head and fondness for explosive devices”. You’re welcome, angry internet fanatic!

** I do hold a religious studies minor from Webster University. No big deal.

*** I can, because this is a thought experiment. If I wanted to, I could put a cat in a box and then kill it with poisonous gas, because that’s just what happens in thought experiments. Deal with it.

Monday, January 04, 2010

A Coating Of Gold

By Abdul Hadi/ANI, *18th century library reopens in Aurangabad after 70 years* - Thaindianews - Bangkok, Thailand

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Aurangabad: An 18th century library, housing manuscripts and a number of precious books including a version of the Quran penned by Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb, has been reopened after 70 years here at the historical monument Panchakki in Maharashtra.

According to library officials, Hazrat Babashah Musafir, who migrated to Aurangabad in 18th century from Bukhara in Russia [sic., in Uzbekistan today (former Soviet Union) ed.], founded the library as well as the Panchakki.

The library treasured about 100,000 books and writing pieces till Indian independence (1947). However, it was closed down in 1970s due to administrative reasons due to which many of the library books were shifted to Hyderabad.

The library presently houses 2,500 books on various subjects related to history, law, medicine, Sufism, religion and philosophy in Arabic, penned by philosophers, saints and scholars in Urdu and Persian languages.

The cover of holy Quran here has a coating of gold on both sides, which has been preserved till date.

Moreover, a holy book written in 1,283 in four languages is also available at this library.

According to Librarian Hafiz Abdul Jaleel, Baba Shah Musafir founded the library to spread knowledge.

“The library was considered to be the largest one in Asia during that time. Now, it has around 2,500 rare books. After reopening the library, many students especially those who are engaged in research are thronging it. There is no entry fee,” Hafiz Abdul Jaleel informed.

People have appreciated the efforts of library’s restoration but say that it has a long way to go.
M.A. Haq, a historian in Auranagbad, expressed disappointment that such a library fell victim to colossal neglect for so long.

“This is a great failure, a disaster, that such a grand and important library has been decimated like this. It was one of the best libraries, once. But it is a matter of pride that with the efforts of the (Waqf) Board, the library would come to life,” said M.A. Haq, Aurangabad based historian.

Locals feel that if maintained properly, the library would benefit people of all walks of life.

[Picture: Aurangzeb reading the Quran. Photo: Wiki.]

Sunday, January 03, 2010

Instilling God In Hearts

By Franklin Lewis, *Rumi's Masnavi, part 4: Rumi's Sufism* - Guardian.co.uk - United Kingdom
Monday, December 21, 2009

Sharia and the external observance of religious rules are only the beginning for the seeker after truth

You attain to knowledge by argument;
You attain a craft or skill by practice;
If voluntary poverty's your choice,
companionship's the way, not hand or tongue.
The knowledge of it passes soul to soul,
not by way of talk or reams of notes.
Its signs are writ upon the seeker's heart,
yet still the seeker cannot ken those signs
until his heart becomes exposed to light
Then God reveals His: Did We not expose? [Qur'an 94:1]
for We've exposed the chambers of your breast
and placed the exposition in your heart

Masnavi 5: 1062-7

Not every wayfarer who sets out on the path may attain the goal, but for Rumi it is the Sufi path which offers the best potential of attaining to true knowledge. But what exactly does Rumi understand by Sufism and the quest? And how does this mystical way relate to the path of Sharia, or religious law? Neither a separate religion nor a sect of Islam, the Sufi path (tariqa) is rather a mode of religious observance and a method of self-training and purification, the goal of which is to orient the believer to a religiously-informed spirituality of experience.

Rumi's Sufism rests upon traditional practices like prayer and fasting (eg, Masnavi 3:2147-74 and 5: 1749-51), pilgrimage (though the idea of 'interior' pilgrimage, and not the outward ritual of Hajj is emphasised, eg, Masnavi 2: 2231-2251), control of baser impulses, and following the example of the prophet. It also depends upon the companionship, or sohbat, of a guide who has progressed along the path and can initiate the novice, helping him establish a praxis and habitus above and beyond what is found in the sharia (eg, Masnavi 1:722-26, 2687-88). The brotherhood of Rumi's followers, the Mevlevis, established a rule requiring a novice perform three years of service to the community before engaging in the sama, or "spiritual concert" – the stylized motive meditation, or turning ceremony, performed as a group, which earned them the nickname of the "whirling dervishes".

This practice is not condoned by all Muslims. And to many Sunni Muslims, Rumi's belief in the spiritual axis mundi, or pivot, who sustains the spiritual universe with the aid of a hierarchy of saints, appears quite heterodox (Rumi himself distinguishes this from the Shia belief in hereditary imams).

So in every age, a saint arises ...
whether seated before you or hid from sight
He is like light and wisdom is his Gabriel
The lesser saints but lamps lit up by him ...
Light emanates in grades as per a scheme,
for seven hundred veils obscure Truth's light
and all these veils of light stack up in tiers.
Behind each veil there stands a certain folk –
these veils – rank after rank up to the top …

Masnavi 2: 815-22

Though some Muslims may find Rumi and Sufism unorthodox, Rumi does not reject the Sharia, but rather assumes that it is the rudiments of religion. As he explains in the prose introduction to book five of the Masnavi, the Sharia is like a candle that lights the way – without that candle we cannot even see to set foot on the spiritual path. But once the path is illuminated by the law, the wayfarer must begin the quest, and his action of walking along the way is the Sufi mode (tariqa). The goal of the quest is nothing short of truth (haqiqa). Rumi also uses the analogy of alchemy or medicine – Sharia is like the theoretical knowledge about transmutation of the elements, or about pharmacology that one reads in books or notes down from a lecture. It is in walking the Sufi tariqa that we gain the experience of applying the chemical reagents to the metal, or following the proper diet and medical regimen. Copper attains to truth in its transmutation to gold. Those who know only the theory revel in the theory; those who experiment with the substance revel in the experiment; whereas those who have been transmuted revel in being gold. The attainment of true health consists in dying to the passions of the world; having died to the world, both the law and the path fade into nothingness, and only the face of God remains in the field of vision (Qur'an 28:88)

Paradoxically, though, this dying to self opens up the possibilities of a theology of love, a vista onto the central animating feature of Rumi's Sufism and his Masnavi, which we will consider next.

In one description (Masnavi 1: 3151-56), Rumi tells why kings seat sufis in front of themselves, whereas they have the royal guards stand to the left, and ministers and secretaries stand at their right:

They give the Sufis pride of place in front
who like mirrors to the eye, reflect soul
Burnished by remembrance, contemplation,
their mirror-hearts receive pristine image …
Beauty's in love with its mirror image,
burnishing souls, instilling God in hearts.


[Click on the title of the article to the original with all the links and to Rumi's Masnavi part 1, 2, 3, and 5]

Mutual Human Respect

By Boaz Fyler, *Religious conference calls for interfaith tolerance* - Ynetnews.com - Israel
Sunday, December 20, 2009

Leaders from all three monotheistic religions take part in conference dealing with promotion of peace, dialogue among faiths. Prince bin Talal of Jordan warns against 'losing our children to hatred instead of educating them to peace'

On the backdrop of the recent mosque torching in the West Bank village of Yasuf, rabbis, priests, and Muslim clerics participated last week in an international conference dealing with the promotion of ideas for peace among all three monotheistic religions.

Chief Rabbi Yona Metzger arrived at the convention after a visit to the village of Yasuf, where he condemned the attack on the mosque. The rabbi said: "for the first time in my life I felt good and safe although those guarding me were Palestinian security officers. I told them we object to attacks on sacred places of all religions."

Among the participants at the conference were also Secretary General of the Council of Europe Walter Shwimmer, head of the Sufi Muslim Council in Britain Haras Rafiq and many other distinguished religious leaders.

During the conference, participants discussed ways to promote peace and mutual human respect, which is one of the cornerstones in all three monotheistic religions. They also suggested ideas by which to promote this mutual respect, especially during times of increased violence and intolerance between religions.

Prince Hassan bin Talal of Jordan, late King Hussein's brother, sent a recorded message in which he called religious leaders to spread awareness to the importance of an interfaith dialogue, and to "rise above culture and politics in order to influence culture with concepts of participation, civil freedom and self respect for all the creatures of creation."

The prince mentioned that we are all "the children of the same creator", and suggested to develop a new concept of global awareness not only to matters of economics, but also to spirituality and conceptuality.
He further warned against "losing our children to hatred instead of educating them to peace."

The prince also added that there is a need in mutual recognition and "safeguarding holy places all over the world – Jerusalem, Mecca and Rome."

Rabbi Michael Melchior took the opportunity to explain that there is nothing in religion that prohibits giving up territory. "One of the reasons negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians failed is the fact the negotiations were conducted in a secular fashion," Melchior said.

Professor Asher Maoz, who organized the conference, called the situation "ironic, even tragic – because all monotheistic religions emphasize values of peace, respect and brotherhood, yet they are responsible for more wars and suffering than any other ideology.

What is lacking is interfaith connection and dialogue," said Maoz.

The conference was initiated and organized by the Peres Academic Center in cooperation with the Foreign Ministry's department of religious affairs, headed by Bahij Mansour.


Picture: Importance of interfaith dialogue. Photo: Eli Saar

Saturday, January 02, 2010

Behind The Facade

By Johnson TA, *Nasir linked to series of blasts, terror outfits* - Indian Express - India
Monday, December 21, 2009

Bangalore: The arrest and interrogation of Lashkar-e-Toiba-linked Nasir Tadiyandavede, the prime accused in the July 25, 2008, Bangalore serial blasts have revealed intricate linkages between several key radical Islamists accused in acts of terrorism seen around the country since 2006.

Apart from throwing light on half a dozen crimes committed in his home state of Kerala, the arrest of Nasir Tadiyandavede has revealed that key former SIMI leaders, members of the Indian Mujahideen and Nasir’s own group working behind the facade of a Sufi organisation ‘Noorisa Tariqat’ often crossed paths and shared notes on their activities.

The loosely knit network of radical Islamists spread around the country, with the encouragement of external terrorist outfits like the Lashkar-e-Toiba, are linked to a series of blasts that occurred around the country between 2006 and 2008.

A Listening Attitude

By Douglas Todd, *If you want to understand spirituality, just listen to the music* - The Vancouver Sun - Vancouver, Canada

Saturday, December 19, 2009

It can lift you 'out of ordinary existence, into the extraordinary -- into spiritual ecstasy'


"The only proof you need that there is a God is music."
--Kurt Vonnegut

Something about music evokes the sacred in even the most irascible, self-avowed atheists.
The great satirical novelist, Kurt Vonnegut, was a Unitarian Universalist who delighted in slamming institutional religions. But when it came to the mystery of music, he melted. He strangely found himself using spiritual language.

So did another famous atheist, Friedrich Nietzsche, the German thinker who announced in the 19th century that "God is dead." Nietzsche admitted being transformed by music. He danced daily, saying it was his "only kind of piety...his 'divine service.'"

This dark time of year -- which is a season filled with music--is a good one for reflecting on the power of harmony and rhythm to transport all of us, whether explicitly religious or not.

Music has a way of lifting us out of ordinary existence into the extraordinary --into spiritual ecstasy.

Every December churches are packed with people listening to O Holy Night and Handel's Messiah and Bach choirs. Eclectic school concerts perform everything from Judaism's snappy Dreidel, Dreidel, Dreidel to Bing Crosby's sentimental I'm Dreaming of a White Christmas.

Carolers walk door to door, or sail port to port around Burrard Inlet. The streets, radio and malls fill the air with festive music, performed by everyone from Bruce Cockburn to Nickelback to B.C.'s Ben Heppner, the Mennonite-choir-trained international opera star.

Arguably the most common gift anyone will receive this December will be musical, in the form of CDs, iPods, concert tickets and homemade song collections for family or friends.

Dan Campbell, author of *The Mozart Effect*, says North Americans "spend more money, time and energy on music than on books, movies and sports."

Why the love affair with music? It's energizing and healing.

And, to put it mystically, as Ludwig Van Beethoven did:
"Music is the mediation between the spiritual and sensual life."

Music may be the most accessible and direct means by which humans can experience, imagine and embody the holy. A case can be made that music is the most spiritual art form and the best metaphor for God -- and that music may be even a form of divinity itself. Like God is said to be, music is invisible, powerful, intelligent, demanding, calming, ordering and emotionally moving.

Karen Armstrong holds out for the divinity of music in her bestselling new book, A Case for God.
The famed British religion writer justifiably says that to understand religion you should understand music.

Music is both rational and beyond rational, like religion. It's based on mathematics and cerebral order, but it's also highly emotional. Music, like spirituality, operates at the furthest reaches of thought, the limits of reason.

"In music, subjective and objective become one," Armstrong writes. "Every day, music confronts us with a mode of knowledge that defies logical analysis and empirical proof. Hence, all art constantly aspires to the condition of music; so too, at its best, does theology."

Armstrong says humans should adopt the same attitude to divinity that they take to absorbing music and other forms of art. Religious insight, she says, is only possible "if people cultivate a receptive, listening attitude, not unlike the way we approach art, music or poetry."

*The Spirituality of Music* (published by B.C.'s Northstone Press), a new book by Canadian John Bird, takes a celebratory journey into the soul of music and dance.

Maintaining that music moves people "closer to God than words," The Spirituality of Music ventures on an eclectic trip through musical topics and forms; from hymns to reggae, Bruce Springsteen to jazz.

Bird eloquently invokes the power of music to take us out of ourselves, to spiritual heights, to what the ancient Greeks called ekstasis.

He quotes jazz saxophonist Charlie Parker's saying, "They teach you there's a boundary line to music. But, man, there's no boundary line to art."

Even more than avidly listening to music, Bird emphasizes the meaning to be found in creating it. He does so with his ukelele and membership in the Iqaluit Community Choir in Nunavut, where he now lives.

I quibble with Bird, however, when he maintains it's "odious" to rank certain songs, or musical genres, as superior. He makes a point of citing Harlan Howard's saying, "Country music is three chords and the truth," which can be accurate on a good day.

But the sentiment rings a little too egalitarian. While it's worth recognizing that amateurs should not obsess over whether they are up to the standards of Chopin or Mark Knopfler, we shouldn't ignore that some commercial music feels heartless and empty.

As the Irish rock-blues-soul singer Van Morrison warns, "Music is spiritual. The music industry is not."

Beyond that, however, Bird makes an important point when he says it's not necessary to compare Mozart to his own mother rocking him in her arms as a child while singing Welsh folk songs.

When it comes to making our own music, authenticity is primary and self-consciousness should be set aside. That is especially true in regard to the physical and spiritual release of dancing, where melody and rhythm can take us into altered states, beyond judgment, beyond reason -- into connection with universal forces.

"Among all the different arts, the art of music [and dance] has been especially considered divine, because it is the exact miniature of the law working through the whole universe," said Hazrat Inayat Khan, a prominent Sufi musician from the early 20th century.

Australian microbiologist-philosopher Charles Birch takes the link further between music and the divine. The best image Birch can conjure up of the God he believes is behind evolution, which he calls the "persuasive ordering principle in the universe," is that of a composer-conductor.
"An orchestra consists of many creative players. Each player interprets the score in his or her own way. But the over-all coordination is provided by the conductor," Birch writes in A Purpose for Everything.

"God is like a composer-conductor who is writing a score a few bars ahead of the orchestra, taking into account their harmonies and disharmonies as he proposes the next movement of the music. God does not determine the outcome. The power of God is the power of persuasion to harmonize the whole."

Perhaps there is a way to put the spirituality of music more directly, though, in a way that might appeal to Vonnegut, Nietzsche and other "secular" people, as well as the host of those who at this time of year affirm the holy power of expressive sound.

As the poet Rumi wrote:
"We've come to the place where everything is music.
"Everything is music; let it play."

[Picture: Hazrat Inayat Khan playing a veena. Photo from Wiki.]

Hoping For A New Beginning

By Tristan McConnell, *West warns that Somalia is becoming a haven for international terrorists* - Times Online / The Times - London, UK

Monday, December 21, 2009

Pass beyond what is described as government territory in the Somali capital — a few blocks between the airport, the harbour and the presidential palace — and you are at the mercy of al-Shabaab, the extremist Islamic group that holds sway across southern and central Somalia. Where it rules, it has implemented laws and punishments reminiscent of Afghanistan under Taleban rule.

It has banned bras, football, dancing and musical ringtones. This weekend al-Shabaab decreed that men must grow beards and shave their moustaches. Its fighters have destroyed Sufi tombs and disinterred colonial-era Italian corpses. Its Sharia courts have ordered public floggings, the chopping off of hands and feet of thieves, the stoning to death of adulterers and beheadings of apostates and spies.

Suicide attacks and roadside bombs have grown in number, leading Western intelligence agencies to conclude that there are growing links between al-Shabaab and al-Qaeda. The agencies warn that the country is becoming a haven for international terrorists.

At the start of this year, Somalia was hoping for a new beginning. Sheikh Sharif Ahmed, a moderate Islamist, was installed as President with the backing of the United Nations as well as Western and regional governments. Ethiopian troops who had invaded in 2006 to oust an Islamist regime — in which Sheikh Ahmed had been a leading figure — withdrew and an African Union peacekeeping mission (Amisom) promised to protect the new Government.

Today the Transitional Federal Government cowers behind 5,000 AU protectors in the piece of Mogadishu that it controls — although recently a suicide bomber struck within the supposed safe zone. In other attacks this month dozens of medical students were killed with three government ministers in a suicide attack. At the weekend 14 people died as Government and insurgent forces traded mortar fire. Every week fresh reports of death and horror cement Mogadishu’s reputation as the worst place on earth.

Harakat al-Shabaab — meaning “Youth Movement” — emerged in 2005 as a cross-clan Islamist militia designed to support the Islamic Courts Union, which aimed to defeat the clan warlords that had devastated the country since the collapse of the last functioning administration in 1991. In their brief reign in Mogadishu in 2006 the Courts brought peace to the city for the first time in years. When they were forced out by US-backed Ethiopian forces, al-Shabaab attracted popular support by fighting a guerrilla war against the invaders.

Many of al-Shabaab’s leaders are radical Somali veterans of the Afghanistan wars. Last year Ahmed Abdi Godane, known as Abu Zubeyr, became its top commander. He is believed to have fought in Afghanistan in the 1980s and is described by one observer as “a hardcore jihadi”. Three months before he assumed his command, the US had designated al-Shabaab as a terrorist organisation. His predecessor, Aden Hashi Ayro, was killed by a US airstrike in May 2008.
Other senior commanders, all of whom enjoy a large degree of autonomy, include Mukhtar Ali Robow, also known as Abu Mansoor, an experienced fighter who ran the training camp from which al-Shabaab emerged, and Ibrahim Haji Jaama who won his nom de guerre “al-Afghani” thanks to years of fighting in Afghanistan and Kashmir.

Because of the growing military pressure in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iraq, hundreds of foreign fighters have flocked to Somalia to fight Sheikh Ahmed’s UN and US-backed administration. They have brought with them a radical ideology of global jihad and some — including a white US citizen known as “al-Amriki” — have taken leading field commander roles.
Their influence is changing al-Shabaab from a local insurgent group into a player in the wider battle between Islamic extremism and the West. “There is increasing control exercised by the foreign leadership of al-Shabaab,” said Peter Pham, associate professor at James Madison University. “It is not just control of resources, foreign fighters and trainers, but of the actual decision-making.”

This foreign influx has strengthened al-Shabaab as a fighting force, but the creeping international agenda has also caused rifts within the group. “There is a serious struggle within al-Shabaab between nationalists and the foreign jihadis who want to take the fight to another level,” said Rashid Abdi, a Somalia analyst at the International Crisis Group.

In recent months this has led to conflict and even some defections. At the same time, al-Shabaab has fallen out with its former ally, Hizb ul-Islam, with whom it launched a joint offensive to oust Sheikh Ahmed in May. This staunchly nationalist group of Islamists is led by Sheikh Hassan Dahir Aweys, who helped to train the first al-Shabaab fighters and is wanted as a terrorist by the US.

This year fighting erupted between al-Shabaab and Hizb ul-Islam over control of revenues from the southern port of Kismayo. This has since turned into a deeper split. “Hizb ul-Islam’s orientation is domestic but al-Shabaab’s focus is on a broader ideological Islam,” said Dr Pham.

Sheikh Ahmed’s enfeebled administration is in no position to take advantage of such divisions. In Mogadishu, a tense and deadly stalemate exists, with al-Shabaab unwilling to take on the peacekeepers’ tanks and artillery and government forces incapable of winning. Sheikh Ahmed’s besieged government barely exists: it does not control the country’s territory, cannot provide security and lacks a popular mandate. “It will continue as long as the Amisom troops are there to guard it. If they were withdrawn it would collapse within hours,” said Dr Pham.

Friday, January 01, 2010

A Shared Shrine

By Staff Writer, *The hidden treasure in Siirt's backyard Tillo* - Sunday's Zaman - Istanbul, Turkey
Sunday, December 20, 2009


Pretty little Tillo is to Siirt what Şirinçe is to Selçuk or Cumalıkızık to Bursa, namely a smaller, more architecturally cohesive settlement to which locals retreat during weekends to soak up the country air.

The big difference is, of course, that, Tillo, being near to Siirt, hardly sees a foreign visitor from one year to the next. Were it in the west of the country, it would be completely mobbed with coach parties, and boutique hotels would be opening on every street corner. That they're not is bad news for the local economy but good news for adventurous travelers who like to feel that they're one step ahead of the crowd.

Finding a way to get to Tillo is the first problem. There are old-fashioned dolmuş taxis as well as minibuses running between Siirt and Tillo, but enquire after their departure point in Siirt and you're likely to be rewarded with blank looks, in itself an indication of how far off the beaten track you've wandered. When at last you do manage to find transport, it will carry you up into the beautiful surrounding hill country and deposit you in the main square of a village that boasts even finer examples of the “cas” houses that are a feature of old Siirt, as well as the beautiful shrine of a pair of famous holy men.

Perhaps the more famous of these holy men was İbrahim Hakkı Erzurumi, who was actually born in 1703 in the village of Hasankale, now Pasinler, just east of Erzurum city. İbrahim and his father, Mullah Osman, came to Tillo to study under İsmail Fakirullah (1655-1734), a scientist and spiritual leader who belonged to a Sufi order called the Oveyssi that had its roots in Yemen.

Like his leader, İbrahim became a scholar adept not just in Islamic jurisprudence and theology but also in medicine and astrology. He's best known for a book called the “Marifetname” (Book of Gnosis), a sort of Whitaker's Almanac of the 18th century setting out everything that was known about subjects as diverse as anatomy, geography and philosophy. Later in life he moved to İstanbul, where he worked in the imperial library of Sultan Mahmud I. When he died in 1780, he was buried beside İsmail Fakirullah in the tomb he had had built for his mentor.

Today their shared shrine is housed inside a honey-colored modern building with a polygonal tower in a lovely graveyard full of picturesque Ottoman-era tombs where the silence is punctuated only by the sound of woodpeckers drumming on the trees. Their graves are protected by exquisitely carved wooden caskets with finials that look like those at the end of pews in medieval English churches, surely some of the most beautiful pieces of contemporary woodwork to be found in Turkey. Buried in the outer rooms of the mausoleum are some of their associates, whose resting places are recorded by much simpler stone markers.

Although the present shrine has a wonderful peacefulness about it, there was one great loss during the course of its construction. Until it was built in 1964, the first rays of the sun at the spring equinox (March 21) would bounce off a tower on a hillside outside the village and then shine straight through a window in the old mausoleum onto İsmail Fakirullah's headstone. Although this remarkable effect can no longer be appreciated, villagers will happily point you in the direction of a small museum housed inside a modern apartment block where you will be able to inspect diagrams showing how it worked. Here too you will be able to see early scientific instruments made by İbrahim Hakkı Erzurumi as well as learn more about his work (albeit only in Turkish).

Most of the weekend visitors who come to Tillo have their sights firmly set on visiting the shrine. However, non-Muslim visitors may be more interested in the village itself, a crumbling but evocative reminder that not so very long ago each region of Turkey boasted its own indigenous style of architecture. In Tillo, as in Siirt itself, that style of architecture consisted of mini tower-houses that looked as if they were made of mud brick but were in fact built of rubble faced with “cas,” a type of plaster made out of locally quarried gypsum. Most of the houses were two or three stories high with flat roofs and highly decorated window and doorframes. The gypsum itself was also adorned with incised patterns, some of them quite complex but most of them looking like the footprints left by the cloven hoof of a deer.

Just as in Siirt, the cas houses are slowly disintegrating under the pressure of rain and snow, and just as in Siirt, the result is that many have been abandoned, including some truly spectacular examples that if they were anywhere else in the country would now be undergoing restoration with an eye to turning them into hotels. Two such examples stand right at the top of the village near a modern mosque. The carvings around their doorways are extraordinarily rich, reminiscent indeed of carvings to be seen in the cathedrals of Western Europe. Inside, the walls are covered with simple but attractive abstract murals in vivid colors. Even the windows are inset with grilles each bar of which is topped off with a trident-like finial. The rooms are quite small, which might make conversion to hotels tricky, but it's a crying shame to see the incongruous Ankara-style houses that have been built right up against some whose owners understandably rate modern conveniences far above picturesqueness.

The cas houses on their own would be reason enough to visit Tillo, but their setting is made all the more attractive by the fact that most of the winding streets still retain their original cobblestones, big flat slabs of limestone that will no doubt be dug up any day soon and replaced with grim, grey concrete. But just as in Şirinçe, the hillside setting means that there are some lovely views to be had from the village, especially in summer when the surrounding orchards fill up with fruit. This is a part of the country that is well known for its juicy pomegranates as well as for some particularly plump pistachios good enough to give Gaziantep a run for its money.
It goes without saying that there's not much of a tourist infrastructure here: no hotels, no cafes, no restaurants serving local delicacies and certainly no handy souvenir shops. For all these luxuries, you will need to head back down into Siirt itself. For the time being, then, Tillo is a taste of the real rural life of a forgotten corner of southeastern Turkey. Go there soon before inevitable modernization comes upon it.

How to get there
Taxi-dolmuşes to Tillo leave from in front of the Büyük Hotel in Siirt; they leave only when full, although you can speed things up by paying for multiple spaces. On the return journey you may be able to find a minibus that will drop you closer to the city center. Regular buses connect Siirt with Diyarbakır and Şırnak.

Where to stay
There's no accommodation in Tillo itself. Siirt has several small and very basic hotels that would be unsuitable for lone women travelers. The one-starred hotel can be full, so advance reservation is advisable. Otel Erdef : 0484 223 1081

Allah Made Us Different

By Staff Reporter - *Celebrating with spirit and spirituality* - The Jakarta Post - Jakarta, Indonesia
Saturday, December 19, 2009

Jakarta residents, along with visitors from around the country, spent Thursday and Friday at the Taman Mini Indonesia Indah park, East Jakarta, celebrating the Suro (Islamic and Javanese New Year) national holiday, which fell on Friday.

The park, usually deserted at night, was imbued with a festive and mystical aura, as visitors flocked for the celebration and various rituals were conducted. Chanting, singing and fragrant scents filled the air in several spots where rituals were held.

Food stalls and vendors selling various wares from watches to wayang (shadow puppets) lined the walkways and some visitors even indulged in night-time picnics with friends and families.

"This celebration is cultural as well as religious," Ade F. Meyliala, the park's operational director, said.

He said the park observed the celebration annually. However, this year's event was unique.
"This year we had an hour-long parade that began in the afternoon," he explained.

The parade kicked off at the park's Sasono Agung stage, proceeded 4 kilometers to the Archipel area, before finishing back at the stage where it was followed by a feast.

On display in the parade were cultural heritage items such as a spear from the ancient Majapahit kingdom era, usually housed inside the park's heritage museum, lavishly decorated tumpeng (cone-shaped rice dishes), which were then shared, and kerbau bule (light-skinned buffalo).

Following the parade and the feast, which included the performance of a traditional dance from Kalimantan, several events were held in different parts of the park.

In the Sasana Adiroso Angeran Sambernyawa room, people dressed in different costumes gathered to discuss the spiritual aspects of nationalism and nation-building until dawn.
The crowd included a group of men in green robes and women in white, a small group of red-and white clad men and women, ornately jeweled women in traditional kebaya dresses, and long haired men dressed in black.

Some of them participated in the parade, and after the feast held an inter-faith discussion on how spiritualism could help shape the country's fate.

The main speakers included those adhering to Islamic, Buddhist and kepercayaan faiths. The latter is a wide category encompassing religious beliefs not covered by the six state-endorsed faiths of Islam, Protestantism, Catholicism, Hinduism, Buddhism and Confucianism.

The discussion was lively, with spiritual "experts" and "mystics" voicing their opinions on subjects such as corruption, violence and tolerance.

Raden Roro Indra A. Sriemandhi, a Sufi leader, emphasized the common thread of "love" in all religions and advised the audience to maintain attitudes of love and compassion.

"I think this is very interesting ... After all, this nation is comprised of many religious and ethnic groups, but it is all because of Allah, who made us different. In the end I think we are all the same in our journey to Allah," a member of an Islamic group from Bekasi said.

Present throughout the discussion were the sounds of high-pitched singing accompanying the wayang show, as well as the narrating voice of the puppet master. The show that night told the story of Luwaring Punagi Drupadi, with famed puppet master Ki Manteb Soedharsono telling the story with dramatic movements in which he made the puppets fight, leap and somersault.

"I come here every year to see the wayang show," said Kasiman, an audience member who avidly watched the show, holding intermittent discussions with his friends next to him.
"This dalang *puppet master* can tell any story," Kasiman's friend said, praising the master's skills.

A short walk away from the building where the puppet theater was held, a cleansing ritual called ruwatan was being conducted in the park's Museum Indonesia building.

Inside a square space marked by a wide black ribbon fastened to decorated pillars, a group of adults and young people all clad in white sat together to undergo the cleansing ritual, said to keep bad luck and bad spirits away.

The celebration also included musical performances from Debu, a multi-ethnic group of American musicians, as well as local musicians Ridho Rhoma and Rhoma Irama.

"Taman Mini Indonesia Indah" means "Beautiful Indonesia Miniature Park"

[Picture: Nitra, Taman Mini's Mascot. Photo from Wiki.]

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Only One Carpet...

By Minhac Çelik, *More steps should be taken to attract more tourists to Konya* - Today's Zaman - Turkey
Saturday, December 19, 2009

Şeb-i Arus (the Night of Union) ceremonies, which are held annually on Dec. 17 to commemorate the death of Mevlana Jelaluddin Rumi, a religious thinker and Sufi who wrote poetry in Persian, have attracted growing interest from both domestic and foreign visitors.

However, for the event to draw more tourists and boost the city’s economy, more should be done to promote and advertise the occasion.

The city hosted more visitors than ever before at this year’s ceremonies, which took place on Dec. 7 to17, stated Murat Peksomlu, a head manager at Dedeman Hotel in Konya. He attributed the rise in the number of visitors to the books written on the life story of Rumi and his close friend Şems-i Tebrizi, who, also a Sufi, introduced Rumi to a new perspective on religion.

“Elif Şafak’s novel ‘Aşk’ [The Forty Rules of Love] and Ahmet Ümit’s ‘Bab-ı Esrar’ [The Secret Door] have been very influential in attracting the attention of their readers to Konya, Sufism, Rumi and Tebrizi. Therefore, the number of visitors has increased every year since 2007, which was declared the year of Mevlana by the Culture and Tourism Ministry. However, we should take more steps to increase the interest of foreign tourists, especially those from Iran,” stated Peksomlu while speaking to Today’s Zaman.

This year more than 1,000 Iranian tourists came to the Şeb-i Arus events because of Rumi’s great importance in Persian culture: First because of he is from the Persian city of Khorasan, and second because he wrote his poems in Persian. Roya Maleki, an Iranian student from Kerman who came to visit Rumi’s tomb, stated that Konya is the second most important city after Mecca in terms of religion.

“After visiting Mecca and becoming a pilgrim, people, especially in Kerman, are expected to visit Konya,” noted Maleki, holding Rumi’s “Divan-ı Kebir” (the collection of Rumi’s poems) in her hand.

Peksomlu noted Konya’s great potential to attract tourists from Iran and underlined that hotel managers from Konya paid a visit to Iran in May to establish contacts with Iranian tourism agencies and lead the initiative to start direct flights from Iran to Konya.

Although the hotels were satisfied with the number of visitors staying their hotels during the event, the visitors from Turkey and foreign countries have not created a notable boost in the city’s economy.

When asked how many carpets he sold over the last 10 days, Recep Topal, the owner of Karaman Carpets, said: “Sadly, I have to say that I only sold one carpet. More tourists visit Konya, but they only come to watch the ceremonies. Something should be done to bring them to the streets for shopping.”


Picture: On the last day of the Şeb-I Arus ceremonies, whirling Dervishes mesmerized the audience, including Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and CHP leader Deniz Baykal.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Pak Gus
No comments:
By Anand Krishna, *The voice in the wilderness* - The Jakarta Post - Jakarta, Indonesia
Saturday, January 2, 2010

The "voice" is gone. And we are left with wilderness.

Gus Dur, the voice that made the wilderness less terrifying, shall no longer be heard. His was the voice of hope, the voice that kept the flame of hope burning in many hearts. Alas, that voice is gone. And yet, on second thought, where can it go? The echo of each and every word he ever uttered shall remain here. Right here, with you and with me - with all of us.

Back in 1998, when I first met him, it was Christmas morning right in the holy month of Ramadan. Sitting beside him, talking to him and exchanging notes. I realized the man, said to be blind, was actually the only one in the entire country who could see things as they were. He was the only man with sight living among us, the blind.

I realized the man next to me was no ordinary man. He was a leader of an altogether different genre. He was a Sufi, a man of God. I remember his words on my tape: "Pak Anand, all conflicts are caused by self-interest . Triggered by mistrust . We need to know and appreciate each other, as you rightly say. Our youth must learn this important lesson."

Commenting on the role of religion and its relation to the state, he said, "The essence of all religions is *togetherness'. There are groups of people trying to change our state's Constitution. We must have a Constitution acceptable to all, and not to any particular group only.

"I work unceasingly to bring about harmony among the different religious groups . There are groups of people busy highlighting the differences among us. There are differences, but not too many. Why shouldn't we, instead, highlight the similarities among us?"

"This is where you, your friends, we all must come and work together!" And that we did.

For more than a decade after that first meeting, we stood together. Rather, he stood together with us, with all of us, in our struggle to uphold the unity and integrity of our beloved country.
Whether it was the religious-triggered conflicts in Jakarta, or outside; the houses of worship attacked, burned and ransacked by the extremists; the so-called insensitive porn bill passed by our parliament ignorant of our indigenous culture and values; or any other struggle - the man stood by us.

Even frail and weak, he was always at the forefront of all our campaigns. He was, he is, the symbol of our struggle, the struggle of this nation toward a truly democratic state, where the concept of majority and minority no longer matters.

Not that we agreed on all issues. I did not see eye to eye on his political role. I considered him too big, a giant of a man, to occupy a relatively small presidential seat. I wrote and said to him, "Gus, you are a kingmaker. Presidents must come and meet you, seek your blessings *sowan in Javanese*. You are too big for the seat."

Gus Dur was silent.

Several months later, accompanying while he ate bakso (meatballs) in his room, I said, "Gus, you are needed outside the palace. The whole nation needs you." He was still silent.

Yet perhaps he was not silent. Perhaps I could not hear him. A couple of weeks later, he was outside the palace - once again among us, among his own people. The messiah of the people had returned to the people. We all celebrated the day.

I remember seeing him in Ciganjur some time back and we discussed world history. I quoted from Arnold Toynbee's A Study of World History. He was excited: "Do you have the book? Do you have it?"

He was like a little child.

I answered, "Yes, Gus, Pak." I always had difficulty calling him Gus - "big brother" in East Java dialect - and would often end up addressing him Pak Gus. A completely wrong expression that made him chuckle.

"Yes, Gus, but I don't have the complete edition, just the abridged edition."

"Oh, that's good, I must come to your place, and see it," he said, again quite innocently. Then he added, "Books must not be lent, they get lost." Once again he chuckled. His childlike innocence was divine!

For the next half an hour, we discussed nothing but books. I was reminded of my late father's meeting with first president, Bung Karno. He had a similar experience. Deja vu!

Abdurrahman Wahid, meaning the "servant of the compassionate one", was a living commentary of both his name and his belief. He served God in man, he served in the fashion of prophets, messiahs, the Buddha and avatars. His religion was the religion of love, of peace, which embraced one and all.

Born on Sept. 7, 1940, he died on Dec. 30, 2009 - and yet, how can a man as big as him die? His voice and his legacy defy death. Gus Dur remains, his voice shall always be heard.

After Bung Karno, he was the truest man of conscience ever born in this country. He was a man who lived his belief. He was not afraid to voice truth as he saw and conceived it.

No, Gus Dur, don't you expect me to bid you farewell. No. You cannot farewell unless and until this country, this nation, your beloved Indonesia fares well. As I write these lines, I can feel your presence, I can hear you. Your childlike laughter remains with us, remains with the people of Indonesia.

I wrote earlier that yours was the voice in the wilderness. And yet perhaps I was wrong. For how can the wilderness remain a wilderness when your voice is heard?

Gus Dur, you remain!

The writer is a spiritual activist and author of more than 130 books.
Read More
The Meeting Will Continue
No comments:
By Staff Reporter, *Somalia: Islamists form Parliament * - Maareg Online - London, UK
Saturday, January 2, 2010

Mogadishu (Mareeg): Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a Islamist organization said Friday they have formed a parliament comprising of 41 members in a conference that has been continuing in Abudwaq town in central Somalia.

Sheikh Abdulkadir Aden was elected as the speaker of the parliament and Sheikh Abdullahi Abdi Mohamed as the first deputy speaker.

Sheikh Ali Omar Hareed was also elected as the second deputy speaker of the Islamist, Sufi parliament.

The delegates who attended in the meeting elected 41 members of parliamentarians and then the members of the new parliament elected the leadership of the parliament.

Sheikh Abdullahi Abdirahman Abu Yusuf, the spokesman of Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a, said the meeting will continue and more activities would be done.

The Sufis who are fighting against al Shabaab militants control many towns in central Somalia.

[Visit http://www.aminarts.com/ for Somali cartoons]
Read More

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Rice For Visitors
No comments:
By Staff Writer, *News in pictures on Thursday* - The Straits Times - Singapore, Singapore
Friday, January 1, 2010

A Pakistani man cooks rice for visitors of the Beri Iman, a shrine of famous Sufi Saint Beri Imam, in Islamabad, Pakistan.

It is common practice for Sufi Muslims whose prayers are answered to give offerings of food to the hundreds of poor who linger regularly at the shrine. -- PHOTO: AP
Read More
For Peace And Tranquillity
No comments:
By Asian News International, *Hindus, Muslims throng the shrine of Kashmir Sufi saint* - Little About - India

Thursday, december 31, 2009

Rajouri (Jammu and Kashmir): Cutting across religious lines, both Hindu and Muslim devotees thronged the dargah (shrine and grave) of Sufi saint Baba Shah Badshah in Rajouri here to observe Urs, his death anniversary on Wednesday (December 30).

On this occasion, a large number of devotees prayed for peace and tranquility in the state."We prayed, as many devotees did, that God bless this country with peace and tranquility. People should get dignity, honour and respect. For all those who have come here with pious intention, may God fulfill their wishes. This is what I prayed to God," said Adbul Rashid Qadari, a devotee.

The Hindu devotees also prayed for peace and tranquility in the region."We prayed to God to endow us with peace and tranquility in Jammu and everything should be all right. May God fulfill the wishes of all those who have come hear and may God fulfill our wishes too," said Navjot Singh, a devotee.

[Picture: View of Rajouri. Photo: Baba Ghulam Shah Badshah University, Rajouri, J&K]
Read More

Saturday, January 09, 2010

The Scholar, The Sufi, And The Fanatic
No comments:
By Nadeem F. Paracha, *The scholar, the sufi, and the fanatic* - Dawn.Com Blog - Pakistan
Thursday, December 31, 2009

Roughly speaking, the political and social aspects of Islam in Pakistan can be seen as existing in and emerging from three distinct sets and clusters of thought. These clusters represent the three variations of political and social Islam that have evolved in this country: modern, popular and conservative.

The modern aspect of Islamic thought in Pakistan has its roots in the ‘Aligarh Movement’ – a nineteenth century effort launched by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan.

His analysis convinced him that the Muslims of India had failed to come to grips with the new zeitgeist emerging from the rise of western colonialism – a power driven by breakthroughs in modern scientific thought and economics, and pragmatic politics based on rational and dispassionate self-interest, all of which stemmed from the many doctrines and socio-political upheavals witnessed in the West during the ‘Age of Reason/Enlightenment.’

Ahmed strived to reinterpret the teachings of Islam so they could be brought in harmony with modern science and philosophy, helping the educated Muslims to continue holding on to their religion but through a rational and enlightened view of life.

Though accused of heresy by conservative Islamic scholars, Ahmed managed to lay the foundations of a modern college in Aligarh in an attempt to draw young Muslims away from the traditional madrassahs towards a place of learning where religious studies would be supplemented by the teaching of modern ‘secular subjects.’

The Aligarh College, that later became a university, soon spawned what came to be known as the ‘Aligarh generation’ – groups of young educated Muslims who would go on to lay the initial foundations of the Pakistan Movement and also become the intellectual engines behind the movement’s central ideological thrust.

Though the Aligarh generation was trained in western law, politics and science, it also held dear Ahmad’s notion that the Muslims of India were a separate cultural community; a thought that was molded into the Two Nation Theory by the All India Muslim League. Much has been contemplated about Jinnah’s ideological orientation, but it is rather clear that the new country was founded on an understanding of Islam that was steeped in Ahmed’s modern Islamic tradition.

The Aligarh tradition that was carried into the corridors of the state and governance of Pakistan pointed towards the new country as being a modern Muslim majority republic, as opposed to a theocratic Islamic State. In fact, the Pakistani state and governments between 1947 and 1977 used (in varying degrees) the above rationale to keep at bay the religious parties’ demand for a theocratic state. But it is also true that the modern Aligarh Muslim mindset was largely an urban phenomenon, associated with the urban middle-class elite of the Punjab and Karachi.

The majority of Muslims in what became Pakistan remained ensconced in the region’s popular variations of Islam. The so-called Barelvi Islam* that became the mainstay belief of a majority of Muslims in the subcontinent (from the nineteenth century onwards), was, as a movement, the reassuring enshrinement of the traditional hybrid-Sufism that prevailed among the Muslims due to the long periods of interaction between Sufi Islam and Hinduism.

This hybrid-Sufism, or Barelvi Islam, became the folk religion of the rural peasants, the urban proletariat and the semi-urban petty-bourgeoisie of the country. It incorporated the anti-clergy elements of Sufism, the jurisprudence doctrines of the more flexible Sunni Hanafi fiqh and, as had been the traditional practice of popular folk Islam of the region, fused these with the concept of overt religious reverence of divine concepts and people, and the accommodating forms of worship found in various shades of Hinduism.

The result was an Indian/Pakistani Muslim polity repulsed by the dogma of puritanical strains of the religion, open to the idea of modern reinterpretation of Islamic law, permissive in its sociology, and largely non-political in essence. At the same time, Barelvi Islam is criticised for being willingly embroiled in superstition and doctrinal ‘innovations.’

Though being populist and agrarian in its world view, Barelvi Islam did not negatively react to Ahmed’s modern Islamic reform. What’s more, it was the constant failure of the political exponents of puritanical Islamic thought to penetrate the thick veneer of Barelvi Islam surrounding the rural and urban masses of Pakistan that in turn facilitated the moderate Aligarh Muslim thought and tradition within the Pakistani state to continue deflecting theocratic maneuvers in the country’s overall political polity.

As various forms of Ahmed’s modern and rational Islamic notions continued to dictate the Pakistani state’s (albeit anti-pluralistic) politics, the masses-oriented make-up of Barlevi Islam became the chosen venue of populist politics in Pakistan.

The left-leaning Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) became the first Pakistani political party to set the tone of its manifesto and rhetoric according to the populist imagery of Barelvi Islam, in the process managing to attract the urban working classes and the rural peasantry towards its socialist program. Consequently, not only did the PPP chairman, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, became one of the first major Pakistani political figures to start being seen indulging in rituals associated with Barelvi Islam (such as visiting Sufi shrines), PPP rallies themselves started radiating an aura of the colourful and musical activity found outside many Sufi shrines of the region (such as the dhamal).

The 1970s in Pakistan thus became an era of populist extroversion. With Barelvi Islam adopted as a populist political expression by the ruling PPP. This saw a further hybridisation of Barelvi Islam. This form of expression eventually became the cultural and religious connect between the country’s secular political parties, the working classes and the peasants.

However, as the popular variation of Islam in Pakistan peaked in the 1970s, the modern variation (tied to the Aligarh thought) started to erode. Though the popular variation remained very much the focus of the populist Z A. Bhutto regime, things started to change at state level when after the 1971 East Pakistan debacle, a move was seen afoot in the army towards conservative (and elitist) variations of Islam, especially those advocated by renowned Islamic scholar and Jamaat-i-Islami (JI) chief, Abul Ala Maududi.

The JI was an early advocate of what became to be known as Political Islam – a modern political theory that forwards the ‘historical’ and theological arguments for an evolutionary instatement of an Islamic state (or a modern-day caliphate) run on the dictates of the Shariah as an alternative to the capitalist-democratic system and socialism/communism.

Political Islam first emerged as an opponent of secular/socialist Muslim nationalism in the 1950s and 1960s. After Egypt, Syria and Jordan’s defeat at the hands of Israel in 1967, secular Muslim nationalism started to give way to Political Islam.

Since the theological aspects of Political Islam were opposed to the more populist strains of the faith (such as Barelvi Islam), the JI in Pakistan was eventually successful in converting the urban middle-classes to its cause after these classes stopped resonating with the modern reformist variations of Islam in Pakistan. Thus, the urban bourgeoisie and the petty-bourgeoisie became the main players against the populist Bhutto regime during the 1976 PNA movement (led by the JI).

But it wasn’t until the arrival of the Ziaul Haq dictatorship and the anti-Soviet ‘Afghan Jihad’ that Political Islam managed to find state approval. Furthermore, as both the US and Saudi Arabia pumped in billions of dollars of aid so that Zia could construct an effective jihad against the Soviet Army in Afghanistan, the more aggressive and puritanical strains of Islam (such as the Deobandi and Wahahbi) too began finding official sanction.

Conscious of the hold Barelvi Islam had in Pakistan, the Zia regime also attempted to penetrate and regulate Sindh and Punjab’s shrine culture, trying to align Barelvi thought with the clergy and jihad-heavy strains of conservative Islam that he was advocating.

The results were devastating. The corruption emerging from the large amounts of financial aid and state patronage Political Islam was able to enjoy in Pakistan during the Afghan jihad, steadily clipped away the intellectual aspects of the theory, and by 1989 (at the end of the Afghan war), Political Islam had become an empty shell in the hands of various Pakistani intelligence agencies who then filled this shell up with what would eventually surface as sheer fanaticism in the shape of sectarian organisations and phenomenon like the Taliban.

This fanaticism is now not only the militant mainstay of anti-intellectual and fanatic Islamist organisations, but, as a rude social discourse, it is being attracting a large number of the urban middle-classes as well who now seem completely detached from their early moorings towards the modern variations of Islam, and as well as from the faith’s more populist base.

Political Islam suffered from its overindulgence in an unpopular and puritanical theological feast that came attached with the patronage it got from conservative Muslim monarchies and dictatorships. By the early 1990s, it was as good as dead due to the many failures it faced to transform Muslim countries into living Islamic states.

However, it regenerated itself as a far more brutal, literalist and anti-intellectual fascist battle cry (in the shape of ‘Islamism’), which has not only been able to find support among the most desperate sections of the Pakistani society, but, unfortunately, also in the seemingly intellectually bankrupt edifice of urban middle-class Pakistan.

Nadeem F. Paracha is a cultural critic and senior columnist for Dawn Newspaper and Dawn.com.

* Click to Barelvi Islam

Read More
Determined To Win
No comments:
By APP, *Sufis, Khanqaahs play vital role is spreading Islam: Sardar Aseef* - Associated Press of Pakistan - Pakistan

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Islamabad: Advisor to the Prime Minister for Education Sardar Aseef Ahmad Ali Wednesday said on Thursday that the institution of ‘Sufis and Khanqaahs’ in the sub-Continent has played a vital role in spreading Islam, influencing the policies of rulers and also the lives of the masses.

He said this while addressing the audience on the occasion of the launching ceremony of Dr. Fatima Hussain’s Book “The War that wasn’t: The Sufis and The Sultan” held at Pakistan Academy of Letters (PAL).

He said that the book is an attempt at analysing various manifestations and functions of the Sufi and his Khanqaah in the sultanate period.

This book analyses the subtle nuances of the dynamics of Sufi power in the social politics of the Delhi Sultanate and how this power affected the relations between the Sufi and the Sultanate, the two most powerful institutions in medieval India, he added.

He said that the author’s objective in the book has been to examine the broad bases of Sufi history in the Sultanate period to obtain sufficient evidence to suggest the need for a new approach and this book shows that the author has succeeded in attaining her objectives.

Sardar Aseff Ahmed said Sufism is very close to his heart as it best projects the true image of Islam.

“We can defeat terrorism by following Sufism as it will help people to understand real teachings of Islam”, he added.

The Advisor said war against terrorism is being imposed on the country but the government is determined to win it.

The other participants, who spoke on the occasion were Vice Challenger of Allama Iqbal Open University Dr. Mehmood ul Hasan Butt, Dr. Tariq Rehman and Prof. Khawaja Masood.
They highlighted different aspects of the book and said by following Sufism people can understand the real teaching of Islam.

The Chairman Pakistan Academy of Later (PAL) Fakhar Zaman said that PAL is planning to arrange International Conference of Sufism from March 14 to 19.

About 80 delegates from 40 countries are likely to participate in the conference and PAL would translate Sufi poets books in 8 different languages.

The translated books would be given to all the participants as it will help to project true image of Islam.

[Picture: Babur Receives a Courtier, 1589, Opaque watercolor and gold on paper. Photo: Wiki, Delhi Sultanate.]
Read More

Friday, January 08, 2010

A Message Of Peace
1 comment:
By n/a, *Top Muslim visits Nelson mosque on anti-extremism peace mission* - Pendle Today - UK
Tuesday, December 29, 2009

A Top Muslim leader who acts as an advisor to world leaders has given a message of peace and love to Pendle.

Sufi Shaykh Hisham Kabbani visits local mosques to challenge extremist agendas and lead discussions for tolerance and moderation.

His life work is to spread the teachings of peace, tolerance, respect and love throughout the world to people of every background, ethnicity, race and belief. To fulfil his commitment to empower Muslims in Britain to live from these principles, Sufi Kabbani has been touring England and conducting an outreach initiative.

On Friday evening, he visited the Central Ghausia Mosque, Nelson, to deliver a keynote speech on love and spirituality. An open invitation was extended to all community members regardless of background to attend the auspicious event.

Imam Irfan Chishti said: "Shaykh Hisham being a leading and world-renowned scholar is successfully bringing to the forefront of the Muslim community important discussions on the need to make a positive and peaceful contribution to the society of the UK. His message is clear and unambiguous for all, especially young people".

Sufi Kabbani condemns all acts of terrorism and the use of Islam to promote terrorist agendas. He has addressed world bodies such as the United Nations and has met heads of state including George Bush, Bill Clinton, President Bambang Yudhoyono of Indonesia, prime ministers from Malaysia, Afghanistan and Turkey.

He continues to advise the United States Department of State on issues regarding Islam, religious tolerance and terrorism.

[Picture: Shaykh Hisham Kabbani. Photo: Wiki]
Read More
6,000 Lines
No comments:
By TE/HGH, *Shajarian joins Gharibpour's 'Mowlavi'* - Press TV - Tehran, Iran
Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Iranian vocalist Homayoun Shajarian has joined the Mowlavi puppet opera project by Iranian theater director Behrouz Gharibpour.

The son of Iran's legendary vocalist will be joined by 16 other vocalists including Mohammad Motamedi, Maliheh Moradi, Amer Shadman, Farhad Asadi and Ehsan Nasiri.

Gharibpour's Mowlavi opera will be made based on the Sufi Persian poet Mowlavi's magnum opus Masnavi and will focus on his life and intellectual development. The score for the opera was recorded in Ukraine, where Iranian and Ukrainian choirs were accompanied by dotar and percussion instruments.

Gharibpour has based his latest work on 6,000 lines from the 13th-century poet's Masnavi and used over 100 puppets to perform the opera.

Known for his extensive research on Qajar puppetry, Gharibpour has staged his puppet plays in numerous domestic and foreign festivals, including the 11th World Festival of Puppet Art in Prague and the 2008 International Incanti Figure Theatre Festival in Italy.

Gharibpour received the Sirene d'Oro [Golden Mermaids] Prize of Italy's 2009 Arrivano dal Mare [They arrive from the sea] Puppet Festival for his contribution to the art of puppetry.

Macbeth, Ashura and Rostam and Sohrab puppet operas are among his best-known works.

Read More

Thursday, January 07, 2010

A Sense Of Carnival
No comments:
By Osama Kamal, *Disciple of immortal beings* - Al-Ahram Weekly - Cairo, Egypt
Issue # 978 / 24-30 December 2009

The auditorium in the Badrakhan Library was rather compact. It is an all purpose room, doubling as a space for arts exhibition, book signings and art performances. Tonight there is a concert by Sheikh Badr and the auditorium is packed to full capacity.

For those who know Badr, this is a night not to be missed. The performer's repertoire ranges from Sufi chanting to sira (folk hero tales) accounts. There is also a lot of religious singing in Badr's repertoire, for how can you have folk singing without religious crooning?

Everything in the hall is oriental -- the decoration, the accessories, even the carpets and chairs. However, a modern art show is still on, and the avant-garde paintings of Issam El-Gabkhangi seem to be taken by surprise by the oriental revivalism of the venue, soon to be taken to another level by the village music that we are here to enjoy.

The audience around me are a mix of old and young. The curious young are hoping for a glimpse of the past, and the old -- no doubt -- are merely nostalgic. Not long ago, concerts such as tonight's were a common occurrence in every Egyptian village. At a wedding or a moulid (saint's day), when people travelled or came back, the crooners sang the siras and performed the mawwals (love songs in the ballad style), and intonated Sufi poetry from dusk to dawn. Tonight is only different in the venue, but the performers are the real deal.

Sheikh Badr is here with a band of four musicians playing the violin, the tambourine, the drum and the rababa (a string instrument). Sheikh Badr is against introducing any Western instrument in folk singing. He sees the use of Western musical instruments as a corruption of tradition. "Our folk instruments are unique in their effect, and they are the reason oriental folk music is so attractive to Westerners," he says. The only instrument of a Western denomination in the band is the violin, and even that is of arguably oriental origin.

The faces of the musicians bear the unmistakable southern features. They have come from al-sayeed al-gowani, or the southernmost parts of the country, announces Sheikh Badr with pride. He is from Kom Ombo near Aswan, a descendant of the mighty Jaafari tribe.

Badr takes the stage with the vitality of a singer at a wedding, singing one village hit after another. Many city people can recognise the songs, as several have been on the radio or used in film scores. He starts with Al-bint beida beida wana amel eh (The girl is white, so white, what do I do?). Then he goes through a dozen of old hits, such as Lagl ennabi (For the sake of the Prophet), Khodni maak yallenta mesafer (Take me with you, traveller). At one point he tantalises the audience with a few stanzas from Al-Sira Al-Helaliya, (oral history of the Hilly tribe).

When I talk to Badr after the show, he reminds me of the late Zakaria El-Heggawi, the great man of folk art, the uncontested sponsor and primary keeper of musical tradition. It was El-Heggawi who first created the Nile Band, of which Badr is still a member.

El-Heggawi toured every part of the country, east and west, south and north in search of songs and lyrics, of oral history and village tales. He died in 1975, but his spirit and art are very much alive, so is the Nile Band under the current management of Abdel-Rahman El-Shafei.
Some of the Nile Band first generation singers are still around, Fatema Sarhan and Gamalat Shiha included. Others are now dead: Khadra Mohamed, Mohamed Abu Deraa and Rayyes Metqal. But their imprint on folk singing is not gone and their memory is cherished to this day by a new generation of performers.

The Nile Band has for decades been Egypt's primary emissary to international forums and festivals, equalled only in this respect by the Reda Folk Dance Company, the country's primary folk dance company. Badr has travelled with the Nile Band to Tunisia, Morocco, Italy and France. He remembers these trips with relish, and is pleased with the recognition Egyptian folk art receives abroad.

Over the past few years Badr has appeared in more than one stage play, including Sirr Al-Hawa (Secret of Love), in which he sang the popular saga of Hassan and Naima. In one scene in the play Badr performed a duet with the popular singer Ali El-Haggar, which consistently brought the audience to their feet. Badr also appeared in the play Taam Al-Sabbar (Taste of Cactus) with Azza Husseini, which had two long runs at the Hanager Theatre.

Together with artist Hamdi Hussein, Badr appeared in the stage play Ghenwet Al-Leil (Song of the Night), which told the saga of Shafiqa and Metwalli. He also sang Al-Sira Al-Helaliya at the Popular Culture Theatre in Fayoum.

Badr is the scion of the Mashayekh family of Kom Ombo. He had a religious education and began singing as a child. His maternal grandfather, Sheikh Hammad, is something of a local saint and his paternal grandfather, Sheikh Taha, is a well- known Sufi figure.

Badr says that Kom Ombo is mostly a conservative community with Sufi leanings and pronounced spirituality, and that him being specialised in religious singing should come as no surprise. In his community people listen to religious singing almost daily. Badr's first album in 2005, Ya Rayhin Al-Madina (You Who Go To Madina), was a collection of religious songs.

Badr's personal style is folksy and cheerful. When you listen to Badr, it's as if you are at a moulid. There is a sense of carnival, a levity of gesture and lots of humour. The cheerfulness does not even disappear when Badr goes into a sira (traditional songs about folk heroes). Comfortable as he is in his sira singing, he does not consider himself to be one the great sira singers among the likes of Sayed El-Dawi and Gaber Abu Hussein.

The big names of sira, he tells Al-Ahram Weekly, not only sang but lived the sira. Badr believes he is just a disciple of those immortal greats, a man who walks on their trail, just as Zakaria El-Heggawi once did.

Read More

Wednesday, January 06, 2010

Lahw Wa La’b?
1 comment:
By Asghar Ali Engineer, *Is Music prohibited in Islam ?* . TwoCircles.net - Cambridge, MA, USA

Thursday, December 24, 2009

The other day I read an article in Friday edition of an Urdu paper which quoted few ahadith (Prophet’s sayings) that music is strictly prohibited in Islam and that those Muslims who burn musical instruments Allah will send them to paradise. Many non-Muslims also ask this questions frequently why Islam is opposed to music? Aurangzeb is also said to have strictly prohibited music.

Is music really prohibited? My studies show it is not prohibited per se. The Qur’an denounces what it calls lahw wa la’b (i.e. fun and play and there was background to it. They Arabs in pre-Islamic times had no serious religious faith and used to indulge in drinking and singing and dancing as we often witness in our societies also. Islam, wanted to engage people in serious activities of reforming social evils and make them obedient to Allah thereby becoming good, just and compassionate human beings undertaking fight against all prevailing social evils. For such way of life naturally lahw wa la’b was serious obstacle and hence the Qur’an warned people against that.

However, many Muslims could not distinguish between the two and declared music prohibited whatever its form or context. While Ulama denounced music the Sufi saints generally approved of it and distinguishing between lahw wa la’b and sheer fun they allowed music as a tool to God-realization as music could induce a sort of ecstasy which in turn helped God-realization. Thus sama’ which literally means listening of music was practiced by sufi saints.

It was for sama’ that qawwali was invented, as far as my knowledge goes, by Khusro, the celebrated disciple of Nizamuddin Awliya who used to have sama’ mehfil (i.e. congregation for devotional music). The Ulama who were jealous of Nizamuddin Awliya’s popularity, issued a fatwa (religious edict) against him for attending sama’ mehfil and the Sultan asked him to come to his court and defend himself. He went to the Sultan’s court (otherwise he never paid court to any sultan) and defended himself by reciting certain ahadith and came away. Maulana Rum had gone a step further and even resorted to dancing to induce such divine ecstacy and his followers regularly resort to dancing and are known as whirling dervishes.

It was because of such controversies created by the Ulama that an eminent sufi and scholar like Ghazzali wrote an epistle on Status of Music in Islam – Discipline and Rules of Music and Ecstacy. It is worth reading for all those who want to understand whether Islam prohibits music or not or if prohibits, what kind of music it prohibits.

Al-Ghazzali begins his Risala on music with these words, “Know this my dear about the fact and situation of man that there is a secret of God which is hidden in the human heart, which is similar to the one that is between iron and stone. Just as fire emits when iron strikes stone and sets forest on fire, a movement occurs in the human heart when it hears good and rhythmical sounds. And unconsciously a new situation comes into existence in the heart.”

He further says “The upper world of beauty and grace and the fundamental of beauty and grace is due proportion. And, whatever is proportionate is the manifestation of the beauty of that upper world. The beauty and proportion that we see in this world is the product of the beauty and grace of the upper world. Therefore, good, rhythmical and proportionate sound has a similarity with some of the wonders of the upper world. And it provides new informations in the heart in the form of a movement and eagerness.”

And further on Ghazzali says, “Whoever’s heart is filled with the fire of the eagerness of God, music becomes necessary for him, so that the fire may be brighter. The same music becomes haram (prohibited) and poisonous for a man, whose heart is full of the love of wrongful matters.”

What is this wrongful matter, Ghazzali refers to? It is lust, fun and music meant for worldly pleasure like the ones youngsters indulge in after drinking in clubs and such other institutions. Of course the Indian Classical music does not fall in this category and it is great art and discipline. Even qawwali and ghazal singing is based on Indian classical music or for that matter western classical symphonies are well cultivated art representing best in human beauty and grace.

Of course Ghazzali does not base his epistle only on such arguments but also on ahadith which tell us how the Prophet (PBUH) himself used to listen to music along with A’isha, his beloved wife. However, for want of space we cannot dwell on this. We will discuss that in other article insha Allah.

[Picture: Abida Parveen in concert at Oslo. Photo from: Wiki.]
Read More

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Beyond Stereotypes
2 comments:
By Sharif Musaji, *On Religious Identity: A Modest Proposal (That Has Nothing to Do with Eating Babies) * - The American Muslim (TAM) - Bridgeton, MO, USA
Wednesday, December 23, 2009

“Of course there is no us and them
But them they do not think the same
It’s them who do not think!”
-Lyrics from Gogol Bordello’s “Illuminated”


By any traditional definition, I am not a good Muslim. This is perhaps surprising, considering my mother is the editor of The American Muslim (though I am aware there may be some people out there who don’t think she’s the best Muslim in the world either), but it’s the truth. And yet, no matter what I do, no matter how I live my life, I will always be a Muslim.

Being a Muslim is now, much like being Jewish, just as much a cultural identifier as it is a religious one. David Cross has a stand-up bit about a perplexing conversation he had with his rabbi where, even after explaining that he was an atheist, his rabbi still asserted that he was Jewish for life, simply because his mother was. Being a Muslim is kind of like that. There is no escaping it. There is no way around it. No matter how incorrect or inapplicable, “muslim” has become a vague, blanket term for pretty much anyone with a moderate tan and a fondness for samosas.*

For most of my life, this hasn’t really been a problem. But with every passing news day, it becomes more of a liability. It seems I increasingly find myself in the awkward position of fielding questions about why Islam is a religion of violence and hatred, even from people who are generally fairly sensible and level-headed. Not that this isn’t a fair question, in the sense that Islam is definitely a link in the causal chain of many recent events like the Fort Hood shooting, but to equate Islam directly with violence is, in my opinion, patently false. Such thinking represents the limited perspective that people so often view the world from. As a fairly visible voice in the American Muslim community, I see this same phenomenon happen to my mother on a much larger—and often much more confrontational—scale.

So even though I am not a scholar**, and have a limited knowledge of Abrahamic faiths, I have a proposal. It is an admittedly silly, naive, and idealistic proposal, but those are the best kind. If it helps, think of it as a thought experiment. Let’s stop using religious labels altogether. Labels like Christian or Muslim. Let’s just do away with them. Cold turkey. Done. Just like that. They are limiting terms that serve only to divide us.

Because really, in this day and age, what do these terms mean? There are dozens of Christian denominations in America alone, and that doesn’t even scratch the surface of the myriad ways that faith can manifest itself in this country and across the globe. One spiritual person might believe that believing in Jesus Christ as lord and savior is the only way to salvation, whereas another might simply believe that Jesus was a prophet, and that we should all attempt to live by his example and teachings. Both self-identify as Christians, yet both have vastly different theological worldviews. One Muslim might follow the teachings of the Sufi poet Rumi, and express his devotion to God through dance and music. Another might find dance and music distracting, or even the tools of the devil, and insist on performing her five daily prayers in a plain, empty room.

People will protest. “Our differences are what make us unique, and what brings us together. You can’t do away with thousands of years of religious tradition just like that.*** We must embrace and learn from our differences!” they’ll say, in their alarmingly whiny voices. And they have a point. But they’re still wrong. Very wrong. These complaints fail to realize that by getting rid of these inadequate terms, we will actually be honoring and enriching not only our various cultures and religious practices, but the unique beliefs of every individual. Because, as one of my favorite professors used to say, religion does not exist in a vacuum. It is an extension and product of societies and culture, politics and economics - really, of everything. So we can never speak of any religion or religious group as some monolithic entity. Religion is just one aspect of a much larger picture, not just in an individual’s life, but in a society’s. Sometimes it is a very influential aspect. Other times it is just a church or temple attached to a really nice gymnasium.

Try and imagine the change that would occur were we to stop using these labels. No longer would we be able to use them as shortcuts to reaching conclusions about people. The terms for the follower of any major religion have now become so loaded, heavy with baggage and all sorts of connotations that it’s almost silly that we do still use them. So let’s do away with them. Suddenly the discussion about Islam’s role in terrorism would instead become exactly what it should be: a discussion on the different ways people choose to interpret the Qu’ran and apply it to their lives, and what role that application plays in the larger context of their specific socio-political situation. Because that’s exactly what it is.

And we would get to that intelligent and nuanced discussion because no one would be able to take the intellectually lazy path of simply stating, “Some muslim blew himself up.” Muslims like my mother would not have to justify and defend the religion of Islam, because every individual’s religious choices, beliefs, and actions would be their own. Moreover, a troubled individual who came to the conclusion that “martyrdom” was a justifiable action would not even be related in any meaningful way to an individual like my mother, an individual with whom the teachings of the Qu’ran and Muhammad happen to have resonated deeply, but who also finds truth and meaning in the holy texts and practices of other faiths, whose worldview is still undeniably shaped by her Catholic upbringing, and who lists among her favorite books Herman Hesse’s Siddhartha.

People might take a step back, and look at the world from a new perspective. That guy read the Qu’ran and decided to hijack a plane, whereas this guy read the Qu’ran and became a conscientious objector, losing his world heavyweight boxing title and serving several years in prison instead of fighting in a war he believed was unjust. What was the difference between the two? This guy read the Bible and became a brave and courageous civil rights leader, whereas that guy read the Bible and decided to assault and murder a homosexual. Why such vastly differing outcomes? Perhaps this simple thought experiment would allow people to actually take a moment to look beyond stereotypes and broad blanket terms, and attempt to truly understand one another. Because people are not simply Christians or Muslims or Jews, they are impossibly complex and endless combinations of culture and circumstance, of socio-economic factors and pure coincidence, perfect examples of what Buddhists call dependent co-arising.

Moreover (and this is getting into super wishful thinking), doing away with these terms would allow us to enter a new age of spiritual improvement. We could all recognize each other simply as fellow travelers on the spiritual path. How much we choose to remain on that path, or even stray off of it, would be our own individual choice. All would be free to learn the valuable lessons presented by various faiths and belief systems, but also to reject the outdated, irrational, and dangerous viewpoints that we must recognize every belief system possesses. There would be a vibrant discussion and debate, and people would be flexible and free to adjust their views and even radically alter their beliefs, because they would not be constrained by labels. Religious traditions would be more vibrant and relevant than they have been in centuries, evolving and expanding in new and exciting ways.

It would be like a sumptuous religious potluck, where every soul could pick and choose the teachings and aspects of different religions and belief systems that make sense to them, constantly trying new things until arriving at the perfect meal. Strict atheists might reject every dish served at this meal, opting instead to bring their own healthy snack to the feast. All would be welcome in this exchange of ideas. I’ve heard people argue that this “buffet” style religion is inauthentic, wishy-washy, New Age-y flim-flam. Those people are mean and use too many hyphenated words. They also miss the point. Sarah Nardi, however, does not. In her article ‘Ramadan Xmas” (Adbusters #87), she presents a fascinating example of how this cross pollination might play out. She posits that Westerners might benefit from some form of fasting during or after the excess of the holiday season. “The thought of candy, cookies, credit cards - consumption in any form - invites feelings of guilt and disgust”, she writes. “Coming down from Christmas - reconnecting to my body’s natural rhythms and my mind’s natural pace - takes days… But what if we were to introduce some elements of Ramadan into our celebration of Christmas? Muslims, during the month-long observance of the Islamic holiday, abstain from eating, drinking and sex during the daylight hours. The practice of fasting is meant to teach patience, humility, and restraint… It is an exercise in discipline and meditation that, once completed, should leave one feeling more connected, more whole.”

No doubt critics will consider this yet another attack on the sanctity of Christmas. Perhaps Stephen Colbert will upgrade it to The Jihad on Christmas instead of just The War on Christmas, if he hasn’t done so already. But the point is that this commingling of ideas and traditions leads to a richer, fuller understanding of one another. Just as Ramadan could help one to appreciate Christmas in a new way, so too could the joy, warmth, and celebration of Christmas serve as yet another reminder for those observing Ramadan to make sure to treasure their loved ones. Also, fruit cake!

More than anything else, doing away with these labels will assuage the cultural guilt I have of not being a very good Muslim. I could instead become, just like everyone else on this planet, a humble pilgrim, seeking answers to thus far unanswerable questions. For my sake, if not for your own, at least think about it.

*This is the part where angry, intolerant, radical hatemongers quote the first half of that sentence, and replace “moderate tan and a fondness for samosas” with “a towel on their head and fondness for explosive devices”. You’re welcome, angry internet fanatic!

** I do hold a religious studies minor from Webster University. No big deal.

*** I can, because this is a thought experiment. If I wanted to, I could put a cat in a box and then kill it with poisonous gas, because that’s just what happens in thought experiments. Deal with it.
Read More

Monday, January 04, 2010

A Coating Of Gold
3 comments:
By Abdul Hadi/ANI, *18th century library reopens in Aurangabad after 70 years* - Thaindianews - Bangkok, Thailand

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Aurangabad: An 18th century library, housing manuscripts and a number of precious books including a version of the Quran penned by Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb, has been reopened after 70 years here at the historical monument Panchakki in Maharashtra.

According to library officials, Hazrat Babashah Musafir, who migrated to Aurangabad in 18th century from Bukhara in Russia [sic., in Uzbekistan today (former Soviet Union) ed.], founded the library as well as the Panchakki.

The library treasured about 100,000 books and writing pieces till Indian independence (1947). However, it was closed down in 1970s due to administrative reasons due to which many of the library books were shifted to Hyderabad.

The library presently houses 2,500 books on various subjects related to history, law, medicine, Sufism, religion and philosophy in Arabic, penned by philosophers, saints and scholars in Urdu and Persian languages.

The cover of holy Quran here has a coating of gold on both sides, which has been preserved till date.

Moreover, a holy book written in 1,283 in four languages is also available at this library.

According to Librarian Hafiz Abdul Jaleel, Baba Shah Musafir founded the library to spread knowledge.

“The library was considered to be the largest one in Asia during that time. Now, it has around 2,500 rare books. After reopening the library, many students especially those who are engaged in research are thronging it. There is no entry fee,” Hafiz Abdul Jaleel informed.

People have appreciated the efforts of library’s restoration but say that it has a long way to go.
M.A. Haq, a historian in Auranagbad, expressed disappointment that such a library fell victim to colossal neglect for so long.

“This is a great failure, a disaster, that such a grand and important library has been decimated like this. It was one of the best libraries, once. But it is a matter of pride that with the efforts of the (Waqf) Board, the library would come to life,” said M.A. Haq, Aurangabad based historian.

Locals feel that if maintained properly, the library would benefit people of all walks of life.

[Picture: Aurangzeb reading the Quran. Photo: Wiki.]
Read More

Sunday, January 03, 2010

Instilling God In Hearts
No comments:
By Franklin Lewis, *Rumi's Masnavi, part 4: Rumi's Sufism* - Guardian.co.uk - United Kingdom
Monday, December 21, 2009

Sharia and the external observance of religious rules are only the beginning for the seeker after truth

You attain to knowledge by argument;
You attain a craft or skill by practice;
If voluntary poverty's your choice,
companionship's the way, not hand or tongue.
The knowledge of it passes soul to soul,
not by way of talk or reams of notes.
Its signs are writ upon the seeker's heart,
yet still the seeker cannot ken those signs
until his heart becomes exposed to light
Then God reveals His: Did We not expose? [Qur'an 94:1]
for We've exposed the chambers of your breast
and placed the exposition in your heart

Masnavi 5: 1062-7

Not every wayfarer who sets out on the path may attain the goal, but for Rumi it is the Sufi path which offers the best potential of attaining to true knowledge. But what exactly does Rumi understand by Sufism and the quest? And how does this mystical way relate to the path of Sharia, or religious law? Neither a separate religion nor a sect of Islam, the Sufi path (tariqa) is rather a mode of religious observance and a method of self-training and purification, the goal of which is to orient the believer to a religiously-informed spirituality of experience.

Rumi's Sufism rests upon traditional practices like prayer and fasting (eg, Masnavi 3:2147-74 and 5: 1749-51), pilgrimage (though the idea of 'interior' pilgrimage, and not the outward ritual of Hajj is emphasised, eg, Masnavi 2: 2231-2251), control of baser impulses, and following the example of the prophet. It also depends upon the companionship, or sohbat, of a guide who has progressed along the path and can initiate the novice, helping him establish a praxis and habitus above and beyond what is found in the sharia (eg, Masnavi 1:722-26, 2687-88). The brotherhood of Rumi's followers, the Mevlevis, established a rule requiring a novice perform three years of service to the community before engaging in the sama, or "spiritual concert" – the stylized motive meditation, or turning ceremony, performed as a group, which earned them the nickname of the "whirling dervishes".

This practice is not condoned by all Muslims. And to many Sunni Muslims, Rumi's belief in the spiritual axis mundi, or pivot, who sustains the spiritual universe with the aid of a hierarchy of saints, appears quite heterodox (Rumi himself distinguishes this from the Shia belief in hereditary imams).

So in every age, a saint arises ...
whether seated before you or hid from sight
He is like light and wisdom is his Gabriel
The lesser saints but lamps lit up by him ...
Light emanates in grades as per a scheme,
for seven hundred veils obscure Truth's light
and all these veils of light stack up in tiers.
Behind each veil there stands a certain folk –
these veils – rank after rank up to the top …

Masnavi 2: 815-22

Though some Muslims may find Rumi and Sufism unorthodox, Rumi does not reject the Sharia, but rather assumes that it is the rudiments of religion. As he explains in the prose introduction to book five of the Masnavi, the Sharia is like a candle that lights the way – without that candle we cannot even see to set foot on the spiritual path. But once the path is illuminated by the law, the wayfarer must begin the quest, and his action of walking along the way is the Sufi mode (tariqa). The goal of the quest is nothing short of truth (haqiqa). Rumi also uses the analogy of alchemy or medicine – Sharia is like the theoretical knowledge about transmutation of the elements, or about pharmacology that one reads in books or notes down from a lecture. It is in walking the Sufi tariqa that we gain the experience of applying the chemical reagents to the metal, or following the proper diet and medical regimen. Copper attains to truth in its transmutation to gold. Those who know only the theory revel in the theory; those who experiment with the substance revel in the experiment; whereas those who have been transmuted revel in being gold. The attainment of true health consists in dying to the passions of the world; having died to the world, both the law and the path fade into nothingness, and only the face of God remains in the field of vision (Qur'an 28:88)

Paradoxically, though, this dying to self opens up the possibilities of a theology of love, a vista onto the central animating feature of Rumi's Sufism and his Masnavi, which we will consider next.

In one description (Masnavi 1: 3151-56), Rumi tells why kings seat sufis in front of themselves, whereas they have the royal guards stand to the left, and ministers and secretaries stand at their right:

They give the Sufis pride of place in front
who like mirrors to the eye, reflect soul
Burnished by remembrance, contemplation,
their mirror-hearts receive pristine image …
Beauty's in love with its mirror image,
burnishing souls, instilling God in hearts.


[Click on the title of the article to the original with all the links and to Rumi's Masnavi part 1, 2, 3, and 5]
Read More
Mutual Human Respect
No comments:
By Boaz Fyler, *Religious conference calls for interfaith tolerance* - Ynetnews.com - Israel
Sunday, December 20, 2009

Leaders from all three monotheistic religions take part in conference dealing with promotion of peace, dialogue among faiths. Prince bin Talal of Jordan warns against 'losing our children to hatred instead of educating them to peace'

On the backdrop of the recent mosque torching in the West Bank village of Yasuf, rabbis, priests, and Muslim clerics participated last week in an international conference dealing with the promotion of ideas for peace among all three monotheistic religions.

Chief Rabbi Yona Metzger arrived at the convention after a visit to the village of Yasuf, where he condemned the attack on the mosque. The rabbi said: "for the first time in my life I felt good and safe although those guarding me were Palestinian security officers. I told them we object to attacks on sacred places of all religions."

Among the participants at the conference were also Secretary General of the Council of Europe Walter Shwimmer, head of the Sufi Muslim Council in Britain Haras Rafiq and many other distinguished religious leaders.

During the conference, participants discussed ways to promote peace and mutual human respect, which is one of the cornerstones in all three monotheistic religions. They also suggested ideas by which to promote this mutual respect, especially during times of increased violence and intolerance between religions.

Prince Hassan bin Talal of Jordan, late King Hussein's brother, sent a recorded message in which he called religious leaders to spread awareness to the importance of an interfaith dialogue, and to "rise above culture and politics in order to influence culture with concepts of participation, civil freedom and self respect for all the creatures of creation."

The prince mentioned that we are all "the children of the same creator", and suggested to develop a new concept of global awareness not only to matters of economics, but also to spirituality and conceptuality.
He further warned against "losing our children to hatred instead of educating them to peace."

The prince also added that there is a need in mutual recognition and "safeguarding holy places all over the world – Jerusalem, Mecca and Rome."

Rabbi Michael Melchior took the opportunity to explain that there is nothing in religion that prohibits giving up territory. "One of the reasons negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians failed is the fact the negotiations were conducted in a secular fashion," Melchior said.

Professor Asher Maoz, who organized the conference, called the situation "ironic, even tragic – because all monotheistic religions emphasize values of peace, respect and brotherhood, yet they are responsible for more wars and suffering than any other ideology.

What is lacking is interfaith connection and dialogue," said Maoz.

The conference was initiated and organized by the Peres Academic Center in cooperation with the Foreign Ministry's department of religious affairs, headed by Bahij Mansour.


Picture: Importance of interfaith dialogue. Photo: Eli Saar
Read More

Saturday, January 02, 2010

Behind The Facade
No comments:
By Johnson TA, *Nasir linked to series of blasts, terror outfits* - Indian Express - India
Monday, December 21, 2009

Bangalore: The arrest and interrogation of Lashkar-e-Toiba-linked Nasir Tadiyandavede, the prime accused in the July 25, 2008, Bangalore serial blasts have revealed intricate linkages between several key radical Islamists accused in acts of terrorism seen around the country since 2006.

Apart from throwing light on half a dozen crimes committed in his home state of Kerala, the arrest of Nasir Tadiyandavede has revealed that key former SIMI leaders, members of the Indian Mujahideen and Nasir’s own group working behind the facade of a Sufi organisation ‘Noorisa Tariqat’ often crossed paths and shared notes on their activities.

The loosely knit network of radical Islamists spread around the country, with the encouragement of external terrorist outfits like the Lashkar-e-Toiba, are linked to a series of blasts that occurred around the country between 2006 and 2008.
Read More
A Listening Attitude
No comments:
By Douglas Todd, *If you want to understand spirituality, just listen to the music* - The Vancouver Sun - Vancouver, Canada

Saturday, December 19, 2009

It can lift you 'out of ordinary existence, into the extraordinary -- into spiritual ecstasy'


"The only proof you need that there is a God is music."
--Kurt Vonnegut

Something about music evokes the sacred in even the most irascible, self-avowed atheists.
The great satirical novelist, Kurt Vonnegut, was a Unitarian Universalist who delighted in slamming institutional religions. But when it came to the mystery of music, he melted. He strangely found himself using spiritual language.

So did another famous atheist, Friedrich Nietzsche, the German thinker who announced in the 19th century that "God is dead." Nietzsche admitted being transformed by music. He danced daily, saying it was his "only kind of piety...his 'divine service.'"

This dark time of year -- which is a season filled with music--is a good one for reflecting on the power of harmony and rhythm to transport all of us, whether explicitly religious or not.

Music has a way of lifting us out of ordinary existence into the extraordinary --into spiritual ecstasy.

Every December churches are packed with people listening to O Holy Night and Handel's Messiah and Bach choirs. Eclectic school concerts perform everything from Judaism's snappy Dreidel, Dreidel, Dreidel to Bing Crosby's sentimental I'm Dreaming of a White Christmas.

Carolers walk door to door, or sail port to port around Burrard Inlet. The streets, radio and malls fill the air with festive music, performed by everyone from Bruce Cockburn to Nickelback to B.C.'s Ben Heppner, the Mennonite-choir-trained international opera star.

Arguably the most common gift anyone will receive this December will be musical, in the form of CDs, iPods, concert tickets and homemade song collections for family or friends.

Dan Campbell, author of *The Mozart Effect*, says North Americans "spend more money, time and energy on music than on books, movies and sports."

Why the love affair with music? It's energizing and healing.

And, to put it mystically, as Ludwig Van Beethoven did:
"Music is the mediation between the spiritual and sensual life."

Music may be the most accessible and direct means by which humans can experience, imagine and embody the holy. A case can be made that music is the most spiritual art form and the best metaphor for God -- and that music may be even a form of divinity itself. Like God is said to be, music is invisible, powerful, intelligent, demanding, calming, ordering and emotionally moving.

Karen Armstrong holds out for the divinity of music in her bestselling new book, A Case for God.
The famed British religion writer justifiably says that to understand religion you should understand music.

Music is both rational and beyond rational, like religion. It's based on mathematics and cerebral order, but it's also highly emotional. Music, like spirituality, operates at the furthest reaches of thought, the limits of reason.

"In music, subjective and objective become one," Armstrong writes. "Every day, music confronts us with a mode of knowledge that defies logical analysis and empirical proof. Hence, all art constantly aspires to the condition of music; so too, at its best, does theology."

Armstrong says humans should adopt the same attitude to divinity that they take to absorbing music and other forms of art. Religious insight, she says, is only possible "if people cultivate a receptive, listening attitude, not unlike the way we approach art, music or poetry."

*The Spirituality of Music* (published by B.C.'s Northstone Press), a new book by Canadian John Bird, takes a celebratory journey into the soul of music and dance.

Maintaining that music moves people "closer to God than words," The Spirituality of Music ventures on an eclectic trip through musical topics and forms; from hymns to reggae, Bruce Springsteen to jazz.

Bird eloquently invokes the power of music to take us out of ourselves, to spiritual heights, to what the ancient Greeks called ekstasis.

He quotes jazz saxophonist Charlie Parker's saying, "They teach you there's a boundary line to music. But, man, there's no boundary line to art."

Even more than avidly listening to music, Bird emphasizes the meaning to be found in creating it. He does so with his ukelele and membership in the Iqaluit Community Choir in Nunavut, where he now lives.

I quibble with Bird, however, when he maintains it's "odious" to rank certain songs, or musical genres, as superior. He makes a point of citing Harlan Howard's saying, "Country music is three chords and the truth," which can be accurate on a good day.

But the sentiment rings a little too egalitarian. While it's worth recognizing that amateurs should not obsess over whether they are up to the standards of Chopin or Mark Knopfler, we shouldn't ignore that some commercial music feels heartless and empty.

As the Irish rock-blues-soul singer Van Morrison warns, "Music is spiritual. The music industry is not."

Beyond that, however, Bird makes an important point when he says it's not necessary to compare Mozart to his own mother rocking him in her arms as a child while singing Welsh folk songs.

When it comes to making our own music, authenticity is primary and self-consciousness should be set aside. That is especially true in regard to the physical and spiritual release of dancing, where melody and rhythm can take us into altered states, beyond judgment, beyond reason -- into connection with universal forces.

"Among all the different arts, the art of music [and dance] has been especially considered divine, because it is the exact miniature of the law working through the whole universe," said Hazrat Inayat Khan, a prominent Sufi musician from the early 20th century.

Australian microbiologist-philosopher Charles Birch takes the link further between music and the divine. The best image Birch can conjure up of the God he believes is behind evolution, which he calls the "persuasive ordering principle in the universe," is that of a composer-conductor.
"An orchestra consists of many creative players. Each player interprets the score in his or her own way. But the over-all coordination is provided by the conductor," Birch writes in A Purpose for Everything.

"God is like a composer-conductor who is writing a score a few bars ahead of the orchestra, taking into account their harmonies and disharmonies as he proposes the next movement of the music. God does not determine the outcome. The power of God is the power of persuasion to harmonize the whole."

Perhaps there is a way to put the spirituality of music more directly, though, in a way that might appeal to Vonnegut, Nietzsche and other "secular" people, as well as the host of those who at this time of year affirm the holy power of expressive sound.

As the poet Rumi wrote:
"We've come to the place where everything is music.
"Everything is music; let it play."

[Picture: Hazrat Inayat Khan playing a veena. Photo from Wiki.]
Read More
Hoping For A New Beginning
No comments:
By Tristan McConnell, *West warns that Somalia is becoming a haven for international terrorists* - Times Online / The Times - London, UK

Monday, December 21, 2009

Pass beyond what is described as government territory in the Somali capital — a few blocks between the airport, the harbour and the presidential palace — and you are at the mercy of al-Shabaab, the extremist Islamic group that holds sway across southern and central Somalia. Where it rules, it has implemented laws and punishments reminiscent of Afghanistan under Taleban rule.

It has banned bras, football, dancing and musical ringtones. This weekend al-Shabaab decreed that men must grow beards and shave their moustaches. Its fighters have destroyed Sufi tombs and disinterred colonial-era Italian corpses. Its Sharia courts have ordered public floggings, the chopping off of hands and feet of thieves, the stoning to death of adulterers and beheadings of apostates and spies.

Suicide attacks and roadside bombs have grown in number, leading Western intelligence agencies to conclude that there are growing links between al-Shabaab and al-Qaeda. The agencies warn that the country is becoming a haven for international terrorists.

At the start of this year, Somalia was hoping for a new beginning. Sheikh Sharif Ahmed, a moderate Islamist, was installed as President with the backing of the United Nations as well as Western and regional governments. Ethiopian troops who had invaded in 2006 to oust an Islamist regime — in which Sheikh Ahmed had been a leading figure — withdrew and an African Union peacekeeping mission (Amisom) promised to protect the new Government.

Today the Transitional Federal Government cowers behind 5,000 AU protectors in the piece of Mogadishu that it controls — although recently a suicide bomber struck within the supposed safe zone. In other attacks this month dozens of medical students were killed with three government ministers in a suicide attack. At the weekend 14 people died as Government and insurgent forces traded mortar fire. Every week fresh reports of death and horror cement Mogadishu’s reputation as the worst place on earth.

Harakat al-Shabaab — meaning “Youth Movement” — emerged in 2005 as a cross-clan Islamist militia designed to support the Islamic Courts Union, which aimed to defeat the clan warlords that had devastated the country since the collapse of the last functioning administration in 1991. In their brief reign in Mogadishu in 2006 the Courts brought peace to the city for the first time in years. When they were forced out by US-backed Ethiopian forces, al-Shabaab attracted popular support by fighting a guerrilla war against the invaders.

Many of al-Shabaab’s leaders are radical Somali veterans of the Afghanistan wars. Last year Ahmed Abdi Godane, known as Abu Zubeyr, became its top commander. He is believed to have fought in Afghanistan in the 1980s and is described by one observer as “a hardcore jihadi”. Three months before he assumed his command, the US had designated al-Shabaab as a terrorist organisation. His predecessor, Aden Hashi Ayro, was killed by a US airstrike in May 2008.
Other senior commanders, all of whom enjoy a large degree of autonomy, include Mukhtar Ali Robow, also known as Abu Mansoor, an experienced fighter who ran the training camp from which al-Shabaab emerged, and Ibrahim Haji Jaama who won his nom de guerre “al-Afghani” thanks to years of fighting in Afghanistan and Kashmir.

Because of the growing military pressure in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iraq, hundreds of foreign fighters have flocked to Somalia to fight Sheikh Ahmed’s UN and US-backed administration. They have brought with them a radical ideology of global jihad and some — including a white US citizen known as “al-Amriki” — have taken leading field commander roles.
Their influence is changing al-Shabaab from a local insurgent group into a player in the wider battle between Islamic extremism and the West. “There is increasing control exercised by the foreign leadership of al-Shabaab,” said Peter Pham, associate professor at James Madison University. “It is not just control of resources, foreign fighters and trainers, but of the actual decision-making.”

This foreign influx has strengthened al-Shabaab as a fighting force, but the creeping international agenda has also caused rifts within the group. “There is a serious struggle within al-Shabaab between nationalists and the foreign jihadis who want to take the fight to another level,” said Rashid Abdi, a Somalia analyst at the International Crisis Group.

In recent months this has led to conflict and even some defections. At the same time, al-Shabaab has fallen out with its former ally, Hizb ul-Islam, with whom it launched a joint offensive to oust Sheikh Ahmed in May. This staunchly nationalist group of Islamists is led by Sheikh Hassan Dahir Aweys, who helped to train the first al-Shabaab fighters and is wanted as a terrorist by the US.

This year fighting erupted between al-Shabaab and Hizb ul-Islam over control of revenues from the southern port of Kismayo. This has since turned into a deeper split. “Hizb ul-Islam’s orientation is domestic but al-Shabaab’s focus is on a broader ideological Islam,” said Dr Pham.

Sheikh Ahmed’s enfeebled administration is in no position to take advantage of such divisions. In Mogadishu, a tense and deadly stalemate exists, with al-Shabaab unwilling to take on the peacekeepers’ tanks and artillery and government forces incapable of winning. Sheikh Ahmed’s besieged government barely exists: it does not control the country’s territory, cannot provide security and lacks a popular mandate. “It will continue as long as the Amisom troops are there to guard it. If they were withdrawn it would collapse within hours,” said Dr Pham.

Read More

Friday, January 01, 2010

A Shared Shrine
No comments:
By Staff Writer, *The hidden treasure in Siirt's backyard Tillo* - Sunday's Zaman - Istanbul, Turkey
Sunday, December 20, 2009


Pretty little Tillo is to Siirt what Şirinçe is to Selçuk or Cumalıkızık to Bursa, namely a smaller, more architecturally cohesive settlement to which locals retreat during weekends to soak up the country air.

The big difference is, of course, that, Tillo, being near to Siirt, hardly sees a foreign visitor from one year to the next. Were it in the west of the country, it would be completely mobbed with coach parties, and boutique hotels would be opening on every street corner. That they're not is bad news for the local economy but good news for adventurous travelers who like to feel that they're one step ahead of the crowd.

Finding a way to get to Tillo is the first problem. There are old-fashioned dolmuş taxis as well as minibuses running between Siirt and Tillo, but enquire after their departure point in Siirt and you're likely to be rewarded with blank looks, in itself an indication of how far off the beaten track you've wandered. When at last you do manage to find transport, it will carry you up into the beautiful surrounding hill country and deposit you in the main square of a village that boasts even finer examples of the “cas” houses that are a feature of old Siirt, as well as the beautiful shrine of a pair of famous holy men.

Perhaps the more famous of these holy men was İbrahim Hakkı Erzurumi, who was actually born in 1703 in the village of Hasankale, now Pasinler, just east of Erzurum city. İbrahim and his father, Mullah Osman, came to Tillo to study under İsmail Fakirullah (1655-1734), a scientist and spiritual leader who belonged to a Sufi order called the Oveyssi that had its roots in Yemen.

Like his leader, İbrahim became a scholar adept not just in Islamic jurisprudence and theology but also in medicine and astrology. He's best known for a book called the “Marifetname” (Book of Gnosis), a sort of Whitaker's Almanac of the 18th century setting out everything that was known about subjects as diverse as anatomy, geography and philosophy. Later in life he moved to İstanbul, where he worked in the imperial library of Sultan Mahmud I. When he died in 1780, he was buried beside İsmail Fakirullah in the tomb he had had built for his mentor.

Today their shared shrine is housed inside a honey-colored modern building with a polygonal tower in a lovely graveyard full of picturesque Ottoman-era tombs where the silence is punctuated only by the sound of woodpeckers drumming on the trees. Their graves are protected by exquisitely carved wooden caskets with finials that look like those at the end of pews in medieval English churches, surely some of the most beautiful pieces of contemporary woodwork to be found in Turkey. Buried in the outer rooms of the mausoleum are some of their associates, whose resting places are recorded by much simpler stone markers.

Although the present shrine has a wonderful peacefulness about it, there was one great loss during the course of its construction. Until it was built in 1964, the first rays of the sun at the spring equinox (March 21) would bounce off a tower on a hillside outside the village and then shine straight through a window in the old mausoleum onto İsmail Fakirullah's headstone. Although this remarkable effect can no longer be appreciated, villagers will happily point you in the direction of a small museum housed inside a modern apartment block where you will be able to inspect diagrams showing how it worked. Here too you will be able to see early scientific instruments made by İbrahim Hakkı Erzurumi as well as learn more about his work (albeit only in Turkish).

Most of the weekend visitors who come to Tillo have their sights firmly set on visiting the shrine. However, non-Muslim visitors may be more interested in the village itself, a crumbling but evocative reminder that not so very long ago each region of Turkey boasted its own indigenous style of architecture. In Tillo, as in Siirt itself, that style of architecture consisted of mini tower-houses that looked as if they were made of mud brick but were in fact built of rubble faced with “cas,” a type of plaster made out of locally quarried gypsum. Most of the houses were two or three stories high with flat roofs and highly decorated window and doorframes. The gypsum itself was also adorned with incised patterns, some of them quite complex but most of them looking like the footprints left by the cloven hoof of a deer.

Just as in Siirt, the cas houses are slowly disintegrating under the pressure of rain and snow, and just as in Siirt, the result is that many have been abandoned, including some truly spectacular examples that if they were anywhere else in the country would now be undergoing restoration with an eye to turning them into hotels. Two such examples stand right at the top of the village near a modern mosque. The carvings around their doorways are extraordinarily rich, reminiscent indeed of carvings to be seen in the cathedrals of Western Europe. Inside, the walls are covered with simple but attractive abstract murals in vivid colors. Even the windows are inset with grilles each bar of which is topped off with a trident-like finial. The rooms are quite small, which might make conversion to hotels tricky, but it's a crying shame to see the incongruous Ankara-style houses that have been built right up against some whose owners understandably rate modern conveniences far above picturesqueness.

The cas houses on their own would be reason enough to visit Tillo, but their setting is made all the more attractive by the fact that most of the winding streets still retain their original cobblestones, big flat slabs of limestone that will no doubt be dug up any day soon and replaced with grim, grey concrete. But just as in Şirinçe, the hillside setting means that there are some lovely views to be had from the village, especially in summer when the surrounding orchards fill up with fruit. This is a part of the country that is well known for its juicy pomegranates as well as for some particularly plump pistachios good enough to give Gaziantep a run for its money.
It goes without saying that there's not much of a tourist infrastructure here: no hotels, no cafes, no restaurants serving local delicacies and certainly no handy souvenir shops. For all these luxuries, you will need to head back down into Siirt itself. For the time being, then, Tillo is a taste of the real rural life of a forgotten corner of southeastern Turkey. Go there soon before inevitable modernization comes upon it.

How to get there
Taxi-dolmuşes to Tillo leave from in front of the Büyük Hotel in Siirt; they leave only when full, although you can speed things up by paying for multiple spaces. On the return journey you may be able to find a minibus that will drop you closer to the city center. Regular buses connect Siirt with Diyarbakır and Şırnak.

Where to stay
There's no accommodation in Tillo itself. Siirt has several small and very basic hotels that would be unsuitable for lone women travelers. The one-starred hotel can be full, so advance reservation is advisable. Otel Erdef : 0484 223 1081
Read More
Allah Made Us Different
No comments:
By Staff Reporter - *Celebrating with spirit and spirituality* - The Jakarta Post - Jakarta, Indonesia
Saturday, December 19, 2009

Jakarta residents, along with visitors from around the country, spent Thursday and Friday at the Taman Mini Indonesia Indah park, East Jakarta, celebrating the Suro (Islamic and Javanese New Year) national holiday, which fell on Friday.

The park, usually deserted at night, was imbued with a festive and mystical aura, as visitors flocked for the celebration and various rituals were conducted. Chanting, singing and fragrant scents filled the air in several spots where rituals were held.

Food stalls and vendors selling various wares from watches to wayang (shadow puppets) lined the walkways and some visitors even indulged in night-time picnics with friends and families.

"This celebration is cultural as well as religious," Ade F. Meyliala, the park's operational director, said.

He said the park observed the celebration annually. However, this year's event was unique.
"This year we had an hour-long parade that began in the afternoon," he explained.

The parade kicked off at the park's Sasono Agung stage, proceeded 4 kilometers to the Archipel area, before finishing back at the stage where it was followed by a feast.

On display in the parade were cultural heritage items such as a spear from the ancient Majapahit kingdom era, usually housed inside the park's heritage museum, lavishly decorated tumpeng (cone-shaped rice dishes), which were then shared, and kerbau bule (light-skinned buffalo).

Following the parade and the feast, which included the performance of a traditional dance from Kalimantan, several events were held in different parts of the park.

In the Sasana Adiroso Angeran Sambernyawa room, people dressed in different costumes gathered to discuss the spiritual aspects of nationalism and nation-building until dawn.
The crowd included a group of men in green robes and women in white, a small group of red-and white clad men and women, ornately jeweled women in traditional kebaya dresses, and long haired men dressed in black.

Some of them participated in the parade, and after the feast held an inter-faith discussion on how spiritualism could help shape the country's fate.

The main speakers included those adhering to Islamic, Buddhist and kepercayaan faiths. The latter is a wide category encompassing religious beliefs not covered by the six state-endorsed faiths of Islam, Protestantism, Catholicism, Hinduism, Buddhism and Confucianism.

The discussion was lively, with spiritual "experts" and "mystics" voicing their opinions on subjects such as corruption, violence and tolerance.

Raden Roro Indra A. Sriemandhi, a Sufi leader, emphasized the common thread of "love" in all religions and advised the audience to maintain attitudes of love and compassion.

"I think this is very interesting ... After all, this nation is comprised of many religious and ethnic groups, but it is all because of Allah, who made us different. In the end I think we are all the same in our journey to Allah," a member of an Islamic group from Bekasi said.

Present throughout the discussion were the sounds of high-pitched singing accompanying the wayang show, as well as the narrating voice of the puppet master. The show that night told the story of Luwaring Punagi Drupadi, with famed puppet master Ki Manteb Soedharsono telling the story with dramatic movements in which he made the puppets fight, leap and somersault.

"I come here every year to see the wayang show," said Kasiman, an audience member who avidly watched the show, holding intermittent discussions with his friends next to him.
"This dalang *puppet master* can tell any story," Kasiman's friend said, praising the master's skills.

A short walk away from the building where the puppet theater was held, a cleansing ritual called ruwatan was being conducted in the park's Museum Indonesia building.

Inside a square space marked by a wide black ribbon fastened to decorated pillars, a group of adults and young people all clad in white sat together to undergo the cleansing ritual, said to keep bad luck and bad spirits away.

The celebration also included musical performances from Debu, a multi-ethnic group of American musicians, as well as local musicians Ridho Rhoma and Rhoma Irama.

"Taman Mini Indonesia Indah" means "Beautiful Indonesia Miniature Park"

[Picture: Nitra, Taman Mini's Mascot. Photo from Wiki.]

Read More

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Only One Carpet...
No comments:
By Minhac Çelik, *More steps should be taken to attract more tourists to Konya* - Today's Zaman - Turkey
Saturday, December 19, 2009

Şeb-i Arus (the Night of Union) ceremonies, which are held annually on Dec. 17 to commemorate the death of Mevlana Jelaluddin Rumi, a religious thinker and Sufi who wrote poetry in Persian, have attracted growing interest from both domestic and foreign visitors.

However, for the event to draw more tourists and boost the city’s economy, more should be done to promote and advertise the occasion.

The city hosted more visitors than ever before at this year’s ceremonies, which took place on Dec. 7 to17, stated Murat Peksomlu, a head manager at Dedeman Hotel in Konya. He attributed the rise in the number of visitors to the books written on the life story of Rumi and his close friend Şems-i Tebrizi, who, also a Sufi, introduced Rumi to a new perspective on religion.

“Elif Şafak’s novel ‘Aşk’ [The Forty Rules of Love] and Ahmet Ümit’s ‘Bab-ı Esrar’ [The Secret Door] have been very influential in attracting the attention of their readers to Konya, Sufism, Rumi and Tebrizi. Therefore, the number of visitors has increased every year since 2007, which was declared the year of Mevlana by the Culture and Tourism Ministry. However, we should take more steps to increase the interest of foreign tourists, especially those from Iran,” stated Peksomlu while speaking to Today’s Zaman.

This year more than 1,000 Iranian tourists came to the Şeb-i Arus events because of Rumi’s great importance in Persian culture: First because of he is from the Persian city of Khorasan, and second because he wrote his poems in Persian. Roya Maleki, an Iranian student from Kerman who came to visit Rumi’s tomb, stated that Konya is the second most important city after Mecca in terms of religion.

“After visiting Mecca and becoming a pilgrim, people, especially in Kerman, are expected to visit Konya,” noted Maleki, holding Rumi’s “Divan-ı Kebir” (the collection of Rumi’s poems) in her hand.

Peksomlu noted Konya’s great potential to attract tourists from Iran and underlined that hotel managers from Konya paid a visit to Iran in May to establish contacts with Iranian tourism agencies and lead the initiative to start direct flights from Iran to Konya.

Although the hotels were satisfied with the number of visitors staying their hotels during the event, the visitors from Turkey and foreign countries have not created a notable boost in the city’s economy.

When asked how many carpets he sold over the last 10 days, Recep Topal, the owner of Karaman Carpets, said: “Sadly, I have to say that I only sold one carpet. More tourists visit Konya, but they only come to watch the ceremonies. Something should be done to bring them to the streets for shopping.”


Picture: On the last day of the Şeb-I Arus ceremonies, whirling Dervishes mesmerized the audience, including Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and CHP leader Deniz Baykal.
Read More